5 WORST Quarterbacks To Ever Win A Super Bowl

Here are the 5 worst quarterbacks to ever win a Super Bowl.

Follow us!

Nonstop Football
• YouTube - @NonstopFootballyt

5 WORST Quarterbacks To Ever Win A Super Bowl

[Dmoney-hzqk]

During the older era's such as Plunkets and Williams, a 50% completion percentage and a 1 to 1 ration for touchdowns to interceptions was acceptable, db's could kill receivers and qb's were treated like everybody else and got killed in the pocket, not to mention the game was based on a run first strategy and hit big plays with play action so percentage didnt matter. Even in the case of johnson and Dilfer, those defenses were allowed to do so much more, those numbers seem horrible compared to a modern era.

[giovanniferme]

Honestly, if plunket won 2 superbowls AND was an MVP in one of them, idk how you could call him one of the 5 worst.

[timmccreery]

You are way off on Jim Plunkett. His career started in New England where he was the #1 draft choice, but in those days NE would not spend any money on their team and Plunkett spent an inordinate amount of time on his back under rushing defenders. He only had one target- his college friend Randy Vataha. The Raiders picked up Plunkett in a 78 trade with SF and struggled after trading Kenny Stabler, until Pastorini was sidelined with a broken leg and Plunkett was given the ball. They won the SB, the first ever wild card to do so. They came back to win it all again in 83. If Plunkett had been with a good team from the beginning his career stats would have been much different.

[heres.ray]

Plunkett was almost out of the league before joining the raiders, but the late great Al Davis was known for taking "misfits" and "unwanted" players if he saw something in them, that's why there were so many guys in their 40s or late 30s on the team like Jerry Rice, say what you want about Plunkett but he gave us 2 of 3 superbowl championships. RIP Al Davis

[eduardopena]

When talking about Baltimore and Dilfer, it wasn't just a great defense that won those games. Jamal Lewis was an absolute beast and they had one of the best place kickers of all time in Matt Stover. There was a string of 5 games that the Ravens won that year solely by Stover kicking field goals.

[sto]

A lot of Plunkett’s losses and picks came from his early years with New England where he was HORRIBLE and is probably the worst draft bust in Patriots history. He really turned it around w us and actually became a respectable QB

[Viper-dcwm]

Jim Plunkett was a great QB.
He started his career with a team that sucked(pats). The guy was a competitor and winner.

[Jake]

Brad Johnson was pretty good that year they won the superbowl. He was also named the teams MVP.

[rodharper]

Doug Williams was a star prior to coming to DC. He won Tampa Bay their first playoff game and got them to the conference championship. The only reason that he didn't stay in Tampa was because the owner was cheap. This is a slap in the face to Doug Williams

[TommyRibs]

Williams and Plunkett were actually good QBs that had ability. They both had very strange careers where their prime was really wasted.

[JM-Ju]

If I were one of those QB's I'd say to myself - who cares, I got my ring and you don't, period...

[johnstjohn]

Trent Dilfer was such a boss that we all didn't even see him win SB 53.

[thub]

In the 70's and early 80's, a 50% completion was the floor for a good QB. It wasn't until the emergence of the West Coast offenses that the 60% became the floor. Passing before Walsh and Coryell was much more vertical with possession receivers needing to quite a bit average more per catch than now.

[jackprecip]

Putting Plunkett on this list is absurd. Those of us who watched him during his day, and the horrible New England and San Francisco teams he was on, know that while he might not have been great, and certainly a hot and cold player, he was really good at times, and was a smart QB in the big games, as his 8-2 playoff record shows. For those who doubt how good a ball he could throw, watch the 1980 Monday Night Football game he played in Pittsburgh (it's always on YouTube somewhere), and watch the pinpoint TD throws he made that night in the 45-34 pinball game against the aging Steel Curtain. One could make a very strong case by using stats and W-L records that Joe Namath deserves to be on this list more than Plunkett but putting Namath on a worst QB list of Super Bowl winners (even if deserved) would be sacrilege and could even get you arrested in some states.

[joaobrito]

Dilfer had no shame in being a game manager from what I have heard, and I think that is a very underrated thing. A guy that had no issue having shit stats and understood that his job was to just not fuck it up. Not everyone can do that

[JoshuaResnick-qdln]

Jim Plunkett? Are you out of your minds?

[OutgrownThings]

Plunkett shouldn’t be on this list. Remember, those stats are representative of a much different league 40 years ago. He was solid.

[conorlauren]

Dick Vermeil during SB XV: “Plunkett’s eating us alive.”
And view the stats from SB XVIII. And the play-by-play. Marcus Allen had 48 yards rushing in the first half. Plunkett had 122 yards passing and a TD in the first half.
Raiders had a 21-0 lead at halftime. Of course they will hand off to Marcus Allen to wear out the clock. And Marcus (along with that O-line) were dominant.

But don’t diss Plunkett. And note: Plunkett was the play caller. Those plays weren’t ordered by Flores. Plunkett was the one calling to hand off to 32.

It’s forgotten that Marcus ran for almost 150 yards in the second half. With a big lead.

[ArkOmen]

You can't say that Doug Williams was a bad QB. He played incredible in that Superbowl when it mattered the most and was the Superbowl MVP.

[kyledamron]

I'm just starting this and I am seeing clips of Jim Plunkett and he was a 2 time sb champion, comeback player of the year, #1 draft pick, and Heisman winner. Jim also balled out in the SB he threw 3 TDs in 1980. Don't diminish his accomplishments. Not someone I'd put on this list. Doug Williams almost took the 79 Tampa Bay Bucs to the SB he was pretty darn good when he was healthy.