So This Happens If You Kill Too Many Innocent people In RDR2? - Red Dead Redemption 2

#rdr2 #reddeadredemption #arthurmorgan

[cafs]

"stop murdering every innocent person in sight." Okay, I'll catcha later then!

[warwickknight]

Arthur: Kills enough people to be at the bottom of the honor chart
Also Arthur: Lets some fish go
Charles: "He was a good man."

[FunnyKnightGuy]

arthur saying "ok i'll catch you later then!" in such a passive and friendly way after getting told off for being essentially a serial killer is the best thing i've seen today.

[ForgottenHonor]

Rockstar: "Stop killing innocent people!"
Player: "Stop spawning witnesses to me killing legitimate badguys!"

[FanboyKisser]

Rockstar: Stop killing people!
Arthur: What are you gonna do about it? Affect the story?
Rockstar: ...Good point.

[N.I.R.A.T.I.A.S.]

Dutch: "We don't need any more problems than we've already got."
Also Dutch: *creates more problems than they've already got*

[OatsMealz]

I constantly had dialogues of Arthur telling people he was senselessly killing innocent animals because of the statistical anomaly of how many rabbits I accidently ran over on my horse

[TheAbhorrent]

I love how the response every one pretty much has to Arthur being a raving murderous lunatic is just:
Hey, buddy. Cool it on the murders

[Nicola_Bailey]

I have had the first Mrs Grimshaw telling off. I recall it's when I went through my 'pester campers' phase. I didn't intend to kill them but they shot at me first!
I also noticed that Arthur admits killing innocent people to Tilly during one of their conversations.

[Wintercomet]

I love how Arthur points at himself and just goes "me?" when Dutch confronts him, like he's playing the hilariously clueless idiot.

[eastern_european]

Dutch: Are you the lunatic who's shooting everybody ?
Arthur with sheriff Malloy's hat: Me? no.

[ClintCODE]

Ive gotten dialogue like this in my high honour dialogue because I killed hostile people. Mary Beth was also disgusted by the fact that Arthur was going around murdering animals but in reality they were road kill mice and squirrels

[Sideway]

I avoided all the Bandit Challenges because I wanted to be good guy Arthur, which meant I had to turn John into a _complete psychopath_ to finish my 100% run

EDIT: People... I know you can easily re-earn the honour again -*The point was I DIDN'T WANT TO!!* it was a "role playing" choice

[nekros]

That she immediately thinks of Bill was funny.

[kixs]

"it's not murder if they shoot me first" -me

[themadtitan]

It's why I try to only shoot members of other gangs, even when doing challenges because I'll either lose honor or trigger these conversations...regardless, I still get them though.

[_JM-]

Only innocent people I kill is people I try to rob who draw first, it’s still wrong but hey what are you gonna do 😂

[mistertwister]

I kinda want to trigger the Dutch one just so it has even more weight when Arthur says “You keep killing people, Dutch.”

[SicklyStars]

I like how they treat murder with the level of severity they would use if Arthur just was going around breaking windows

[supEnoc]

Oh yeah I remember that, I went a little rampage at the beginning too. But then as Arthur got sick it genuinely made me change along with him. Because what good is money to a dying man? Got the good ending without even knowing there are multiple ones and damn was it worth it.