3 Horrifying TRUE New Year's Eve Horror Stories

Here are 3 allegedly true New Year's Eve horror stories to close out 2023.

If you enjoy this type of content and would like to see more of it & support the channel, feel free to subscribe and turn on notifications.

Anything with poorly structured sentences and grammar will not be read, so please just make them neat and understandable. Please also state how you would like your name to be credited in a video.

[eljox]

since this is probably the last video for this year, I want to thank you mr. nightmare in the name of all your fans, it was a year with mostly stories and not your usual countdowns, videos with very interesting topics that only become better because of your narration and style, your consistency this year was at the top so thank you for bringing us the best content, most of us grew up with you and your videos are the best comfort that we seek each week, happy new year nightmare fans, can't wait for next year's videos!

[karakreativevlog]

If that first story is true, that guy is a complete idiot for letting a random person into someone else's house.

[mage]

Pro tip everyone: Don't let strangers you have never met into your house, let alone your friends house.

[sammyscrappy]

The guy in the first story is crazy. Who just let's a stranger into their friends house that they don't know? If I'm watching a friend's house and dog and someone comes to the door I'm not answering and sure as hell not letting them in the house and to said friends room. That's crazy

[andrewg.]

Pro tip: If watching a house find out who may visit and if they are ok to enter. People often broadcast on social media when they are away, either on a trip or for the night. And they think nothing of it.

[andrewmichaelscollectibles]

I find it quite stupid that the person in the first story was 35 and didn't find some way to confirm that the girl was Alex's girlfriend. It's even worse that not only is he 35 so he's logical enough, but he texts Alex AFTER the girl is already in the house. He clearly was in contact with Alex so he could have confirmed easily.

[elpajero]

Dude in the first story gotta be the worst dog watcher ever lmao. At least check w the homeowner to see who can come in lmao😭😭

[Rock_on_gold_dust_woman]

The person who wrote the story 2 has an obsession with telling people they had a suite. I swear they mentioned it 87 times. Lol

[nayglizzo]

New ideas for the new year:
1. Prom stories
2. Graduation stories
3. Birthday party stories
4. Substitute teacher stories
5. Search n Rescue stories
6. Cruise ship stories
7. Bachelor/ bachelorette party stories
8. Warehouse stories
9. High school/college football game stories (or any sport games)
10. Sneaking Out stories

[daviep]

The first guy in story #1 really irritated me. Who opens the door for s a stranger in their friends house?

[stevemorison]

“It was December 31st, New Years Eve”

My floor is made of floor

[ludicrousmodel]

In some cases, it might be better not to mention that you're calling the cops. That way, they intruder won't know to leave and they'll be more likely to get caught.

[HeisenbergFam]

8 years later and Mr. Nightmare still has fun telling stories, respect

[mistybloo]

It's crazy how many videos came out this year, I'm very thankful for this channel's consistency. It’s been a great time watching every single one of them. I hope you have a good New Year's celebration, Mr. Nightmare!

[Itsme-fbob]

Man, I'm so ticked off. I wrote out a true story about what happened to me 20 years ago, specifically to send in to Mr Nightmare. I wrote the whole thing out. Proofread it, and then went to save it. My computer glitches, and the whole thing is gone. I don't know when I'll write it all over again. So discouraging.

[optimusproductions]

An actual New Year’s sequel we deserve

[bzisniper]

number 2 sounded like a possession tbh, black eyes, black mouth, uncontrollable cackling, growling, hissing, crawling, all things that happen during possessions

[latimeriasdream]

Bruh whoever submitted the first story had me clenching my phone in PURE frustration. Who the fuck lets in some random woman into the house and who also claims to be your friend’s girlfriend WITHOUT checking with said friend if this is legit?? Like I know some people might not be involved in their friend’s personal lives, but at least check with them if someone claiming to be their partner shows up.

[shahinarahaque]

Man, if I saw a deranged woman growling and crawling like that, I'd probably think that she was either a demon or Ishowspeed's long-lost cousin.
Edit: Tbf, there isn't much difference between a demon and speed to even begin with.

[josephscaduto]

Always felt like this topic wasn’t shared enough. Great to see you finally make another NYE video. Happy New Year, Mr. Nightmare! You’ll always be the best