Do Jews and Arabs Really Have Different Ancestors?

In this episode, you can check the current distribution of Y-DNA haplogroup J1 by country and the famous individuals belonging to J1. Also, through the phylogenetic tree of Haplogroup J1, the time of occurrence and prominent formation places of descendants by era are introduced. Finally, the ancient DNA of J1 was mapped by period.

00:33 introduction
01:40 Present frequency of J1
03:59 Famous individuals belong to J1
07:52 J1 phylogenetic tree
09:33 Ancient Y-DNA of J1

[geonomad]

00:33 introduction
01:40 Present frequency of J1
03:59 Famous individuals belong to J1
07:52 J1 phylogenetic tree
09:33 Ancient Y-DNA of J1

[scoobydoo]

Interesting, though people have mixed and intermingled over the millennia. A linguistic study, which in fact is a cultural study, clearly shows that both Jewish, Aramaic and Arabic languages share the same Semitic root/origin and are relatives. Interestingly enough, they also share the same religious root, as they are both abrahamic religions.

[ladaylyn]

The only group you did not mention is the Amhara people of Ethiopia. Their male population carry the J-M267 segment of the J1 upto 70%.

[defender]

This is why saying anti-Semitic doesn't really apply unless you hate all of them.

[Muaz]

The study in Khartoum can be generalized to more than 20 million people. Khartoum is not an isolated region in Sudan. Most Khartoum inhabitants are called Arabs in Sudan. They are the inhabitants of most major cities in Sudan

[MariaNI-yfbz]

@01:40 North Africa is predominately E1b1-M81(the Berber or Amazigh marker) and E1b1b-M78(not macro E-M78*=Iberomaurusian)and indigenous to the Nile Valley, so this map is wrong and based only on assumptions. North Africa is not " Arab" its Amazigh (Berber) and Egyptian/ Coptic, still of indigenous, predominantly local North African(100 precent Eurasian) origin. The near Eastern conquest that converted the people into Islam made virtually no impact on the genomic local scale. It was mainly about leadership, not to 'replace' nor that there is any evidence of any sort of "ge n ocide" Do not confuse the European migrations to the new world with the history of the MENA region.

[davidchurch]

Ah, but the ancient distribution of J1 does not reflect where it was most common in anceint times, necessarily; instead, it represents only those places where suitably-preserved bodies from which we could isolate DNA, have happened to be found, and tested. Any inferences made from this very limited sampling of the ancient DNA, being less than 1 per million (or even more!) could be extremely inaccurate.

[N-iqx]

J1 - political and ideological leadership
J2 - Commercial and artistic intelligence
R1a - Military strategy and mathematics
R1b - Organization and work
E1b1b - Adaptability and social intelligence
I - Discipline and individuality

[Mr.w]

I am Saudi and Arab, and the thing I am most surprised about is that I have cousins in Scotland

[matityahubenavraham]

I am J2 and I love J1 brothers and all the other people I love, all the people in the world are brothers ❤️

[gaz]

J1 here from Manchester UK, not sure how my paternal ancestor got here but this city was Roman in the past and had three forts nearby (Mamucium, Castleshaw & Ardotalia). All could have had auxillary soldiers from the middle east stay at those forts. Traders also came to the UK from the middle east too in Roman times. Interesting how big noses (Roman nose) also run on my father's side. I wonder if there's a genetic trait there with J people?

[chrisclassical]

i would imagine every christian and every muslim was once in some way related to a person with the jewish faith. myself personally an irish roman Catholic can trace my genes according to 23 and me to be scandanivan and european. not a hint of middle eastern in me despite even having neanderthal genes. what people can't seem to get their heads around that there is no connection between a faith belief, ethnicity and genetic groups.

[Miki-flez]

It would be cool that you commented where J1 is one of many.
And in which remains is the dominant in your map of fossils throughout time

[stellajohnson-vives]

I am of Italian descent. My haplop is J1. FGC13863. I do not see this in your tree distribution. Is it under another group?

[quadejaworski]

Nice Video! I'm excited for J2. My friend's paternal line is from France and his haplogroup is J-M172. Is J2 and J-M172 considered the same branch?

[joanhuffman]

Even in the Bible, Abraham and Isaac had sons whose descendants were not among the Jews. Abraham was the father of Isaac by his wife Sarah, and father of Ismael by Hagar, and the father of Zimran, Jokshan, Medan, Midian, Ishbak, and Shuah, by Keturah the concubine he took after the death of Sarah. Isaac was the father of Jacob and Esau. Other men who shared the same Y chromosome as Abraham were Lot and his sons Moab and Amnon, Laban and his sons too as they were descendants of Terah, the father of Abraham. Only Jacob's children are considered Jews, but they had relatives.

[bircruz]

Of course. Jew is religion, Arab is ethnicity. Catholic is religion, Italy is a nation. Mixing apples and oranges. Mental clarity is wanting.

[BobJohnson]

Has this channel explored the Khazar connection?

[timjb]

I can't tell if the narrator is a person or a computer generated voice, but it really bugs me that there are so many mispronounciations in this video.

[aimenaymen]

Actually you have to differentiate between Israelites and Jews Israelites are 12 arabic tribes formed by the 12 sons of Isaac however Je some of the Jews are Nordic and kzar tribes that doesn't have to do with the area and they embraced the Judaism most of them are ishkinaz