D5 Render vs Lumion - Exterior 3d Render #Shorts

Can you guess which is which? Quick video comparison!

If you have any questions, ask me in the comments below the video.

#d5render #lumion #3drender

[allenyumang]

1st one is Lumion. The sun flare is so given and the vegetation in the background that is unique to Lumion. 2nd one is D5, it has that cinematic LUT.

[DrewArchitects]

Both are really well done!
The first one is done in lumion.
Would really appreciate hearing your opinion if one software is better than the other, how they compare with regards to ease of use, time to render etc.

[seanfarrellsullivanhasemotions]

Right away I found a tell that shows the first being Lumion because of the Leafless Tree in the right foreground that is specifically found in Lumion's object collection. Close tho, the D5 was still pretty good.

[renanrodriguez]

1st clip is lumion because it has smoother frames per second (60fps) while 2nd clip is D5 render which yet supported 30 fps video export

[homedesignhub]

I really thought 2nd video was Lumion.. true to life indeed great scene

[angellomarques]

Nuno, I think that both are good as well (I decide to do a specific job about who is give the equilibrium between time render and quality). Thanks for each works/tips that you share with us!

[RafaelGomes-gwse]

No idea, but I do prefer the first one. Something weird about 2nd video. Same displacement maps on both videos?

[bradvanburen]

I think the 1st is Lumion because of the contrails and lens flare. The bokeh flare in the 2nd is not much I see in Lumion even though I know it has a bokeh effect.

[firmanthered]

There's a lot to break down on these videos
1. Sun disk is totally different, you can see in D5 that its not giving you much glare but it's still there
2. Overall texture I think D5 works better not only in showing displacements but also on how it reacts with normal maps
3. Framerate wise tho D5 looked a lot smoother (probably 60 fps ?) well I wonder how long did it take to render
I've never personally tried D5 myself but I'm well aware of which one is Lumion, and I must say, I'm kind of interested on trying D5

[adollar]

Second one is Lumion. I might be wrong, but I have a strong feeling

[vcf]

D5 at least in this video! Would be cool to be able to see them side by side too!

[MeleeKillerYT]

First one luminous and second D5, found out using flares. xD

[D_mds_dsgn]

2d part is D5, better gamma in shadows, visible more details.

[brendanpace]

2nd one looks like Lumion displacement to me, but I could be wrong.

[catsven]

I’m perplexed by one thing In the scene .. how can you get such detailed rock/ground in both ?!! I’m a D5 user and I know that displacement feature is very poor .. so I guess it’s an object not a texture ..

[leoleo-hydg]

First lumion second d5 for the lens flare

[laibation]

Maybe~the second is D5，Lens Flares and sky?

[Anandkssree]

Hai can u suggest workstation or PC specification for working lumion and unreal engine

[JayMikeWillingham]

First one is Lumion and the Second is D5.

[ianbarnett]

2nd is Lumion because of the moving trees, I don't think D5 has this effect.