4 Very Scary TRUE Fishing Horror Stories

I've only done this topic one other time almost a decade ago, and a lot of you have requested it ever since. So here are four allegedly true fishing horror stories recounted by viewers.

If you enjoy this type of content and would like to see more of it & support the channel, feel free to subscribe and turn on notifications.

Anything with poorly structured sentences and grammar will not be read, so please just make them neat and understandable. Please also state how you would like your name to be credited in a video.

[jessicamoga]

the guy in the first story left the lake as soon as he saw a potential threat of the man, proceeded to stay aware of his surroundings, didnt open the door when he had a bad feeling, had a weapon near himself when his life was at risk and made his presence agressive, made reports to proper authority, spent the next days continuing to stay precautious. smart choice after smart choice lead him to the best case scenario unlike a lot of other people in these stories. be like THAT man

[pablodelsegundo]

#1 - nice to hear a story where the protagonist has a lick of sense and is properly armed out in the wilderness!

[hpalpha]

As an old man that wanders the forest alone at night, I wonder if people are terrified of me

[caseykim-qkrf]

i've been watching your channel for about 5 years now. i don't like listening to other horror story telling channels because the way they try to make their voice sound scary. you tell a story without trying to make it sound scary but it still always frightens me. your good at what you do. i was never into horror until discovering you. i'm a very loyal subscriber, for a long time i would just search you on safari everyday to watch your videos, eventually i downloaded youtube just to watch your videos and get notifications when you uploaded. i watched every single one of your videos, some of them multiple times. i've been watching you since elementary school, im in middle school now and when i get to highschool i hope you'll still be uploading. never quit doing what you do! your amazing.

[evanhorrofan]

Thank you for making the past eight years of my life filled with fright and entertainment. Never retire!!!

[inventist]

"Give a man a fish, he'll eat for a day. Watch a guy throw a gun into a lake, and you'll never fish at that lake again."

[Jayden-lrmm]

The second story with the tribal attire was pure terror and adrenaline pumping as when they were running to the boat. Just imaging if the tribe would’ve caught up and captured them

[FrncoLLC]

Ngl, because of Mr. Nightmare I’ve learned so many survival instincts lessons in my life. Just hearing these stories made me realize how scary the world is. This man has really saved my life so many times so thank you so much. Recently had my newborn and can’t wait to show him Mr. Nightmare videos so he can be smart and self aware of this world. Truly man thank you, you have no idea how these stories have changed my life over the years. I remember your very first videos especially them pizza deliveries or them true creepy stories. From the bottom of my heart thank you.

[Kaceykoley]

The 2nd story is literally terrifying. Imagine what would’ve happened if they didn’t get back to the boat in time

[sav]

dude in the first story was way too nice I would’ve been shooting the moment I heard the window break lmaoo

[NJDJ]

Story 2 - bro that scream @12:26 terrified the hell outta me! Glad OP, his dad, & few other boys got out of the danger zone!

[vexinicty]

Not gonna lie and say I'm a long time viewer for 8+ years, but it's upcoming to me listening to this channel for 4 years. It's been amazing from when I was a little bud during covid to now graduating. Thanks Mr Nightmare!

[ProjectAnimate]

Fishing alone at night is a horror story itself tbh

[drb]

I like being alone but I'll never hike or go camping unarmed that's just crazy.

[Jeriie]

as mr nightmare gets older his voice ages like wine, love this guy fr been watching him for years now

[ashleybrooke]

The most terrifying thing that ever happened to me was pretty ordinary but it scared the hell out of me when I was little & my dad & some of his buddies were ocean fishing on a boat around Mulege in Mexico. This huge hammerhead shark swam up out of nowhere to check out the boat and then just silently went back down into the water. I was maybe six at the time & it gave me nightmares.

To this day, my dad will tease me about it because he said it was only about eight feet long but that's big enough. That's when I knew I'd never go scuba diving in the ocean.

[Bashycat]

The fact that the guy in the first story had a loaded gun near him in the moment is a great example of why you should always have a weapon for defense near you at all times.
That is a prime example in the first story.
Props to the dude for defending himself.

[bluebullbuffalo]

I truly believe that through mr.Nightmares videos a few sketchy situations were avoided

[Smarte_Nptune]

Tbh mr.nightmare is one of some you tubers who are still posting after 6-15 years respect for this guy

[edwardtdm]

That second story is honestly chilling. Just imagine if they hadn't made it back to the boat in time! 😱