History of the Celtic Languages, part 2 - P/Q hypothesis

History of the Celtic Languages, part 2 - P/Q hypothesis, Proto-Celtic, P-Celtic, Q-Celtic, Noric, Lepontic, Brythonic, Goidelic, Gaulish, Celtiberian, Gallaecian, Galatian, Pictish, Welsh, Irish, Breton, Scottish Gaelic, Cumbric, Cornish, Manx

Music
Celtic Impulse - Celtic - Kevin MacLeod
November - Joey Pecoraro

[Ali-bulo]

Manx and Cornish have already been revived and Manx has native speakers.

[bluemymnd]

No matter how you slice it, the celtic people's fate is always a sad one. Me writing this comment in english just proves the point

[bbenjoe]

Saint Paul the Apostle wrote a letter to the Galatians, which is in the Bible.
When I googled out who the Galatians were... now that was a surprise. Celts in Asia!

[Thomas-gnbv]

In southwest Germany many mountains and almost all rivers have still Celtic names.
Mountains: Ipf, Teck, Neuffen.
Rivers: Lauter, Fils, Kocher, Jagst, Neckar, Donau.
The word " Burren" has still the same meaning like in Irish.

[leonardo_fratila]

The decline of the celtic langueges and cultures is always very tragic to see. At least the celtic ancestry is still doing alright.
Also, very cool video!❤👍💯🫡

[SirBoggins]

'Welsh is of this soil, this island, the senior language of the men of Britain; Welsh is beautiful.'

- JRR Tolkien 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿

[SirBoggins]

"Poetry is a special use of language that opens onto the real. The business of the poet is truth telling, which is why in the Celtic tradition no one could be a teacher unless he or she was a poet."

-Huston Smith

[ErmisSouldatos]

Long ago, the Celtic nations lived in harmony, but everything changed when the Senones attacked

[tersus]

Celts were really unlucky to be sandwitched between Romans and Germanic people

[pretzelearthsociety]

Ag troid, ag sárú, agus ag fás. Teangacha ceilteacha beo i gcónaí 🇮🇪🇮🇲🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿🇫🇷

[Syllaeus]

look at the celts peacefully spreading into Iberia and Anatolia…so cute ☺️

[newg]

I also agree with the Q-Celtic in Britain first theory then being replaced by Gaulish like language (Brythonic). Only notable thing wrong is the Isle of Man which was Brythonic then became Gaelic in the 5-6th century ad as Irish settlers changed the language of the island to a very early form of manx

[ErmisSouldatos]

One of the very few groups to have less speakers now than they did two thousand years ago (and I mean in absolute terms, not as a percentage of global population). All of that despite the fact that world population has grown by about 40 times since then.

[ussrwrestling]

Кельтским языкам- не повезло! В Галлии (нынешней Франции), в Иберии(Испании и Португалии) - кельтские языки выместила "народная латынь" (на ее основе потом развились французский, испанский и португальский языки). В Британии шло хронические вытеснение кельтских языков - англо-саксонским и ново-английским языком!! )))

Но КРОВЬ, "кровь", генетика остались в основном кельтскими!

[hatemastertenn]

come back soon celtic 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[minimodecimomeridio]

In my opinion the subdivision of the Celtic languages in Gallo-Brythonic (P-Celtic) and Ibero-Goidelic (Q-Celtic) makes much more sense than the traditional classification between insular and continental languages. Welsh and Ancient Gaulish, for example, appear to be much more closely related than Welsh and Irish.

[dieletztekavallerie]

Could you also update some of your videos (like Uralic, Turkic, Germanic, Slavic etc.)? This video is much better, compared to the previous Celtic video.

[rafaxd]

Celtiberic and Galaecian (also is disputed now if Galaecians are celtic or more like Lusitanians and Vetonians) are two of the many Celtic tribes that lived in the Iberian Peninsula at that moment, like the Vaccei, the Asturians, the Cantabrians, the Carpetans or the Celtici. Also, Autrigons, Vardulians and Beronians were celtic and ocupy the actual region of the Basque Country (in northern Spain), which is not coloured in the map.

[madjames]

By 200, were Gallia and Hispania fully Romanized, having Late Latin as common language?

[madjames]

I saw a study that speculated that Philistines/Sea People were Celtic, based on recorded names of people and places.