Did Muhammad really exist?

[BloggingTheology]

I have added subtitles to the video in a number of languages

[SSAAMM]

In just a few months, I learnt from this channel what I did not learn from twelve years of "Islamic studies" in school. God bless you Paul.

[sanamt]

Wow I had no clue there were people who actually speak this way. Thank you once again brother Paul. Mashallah we all learn so much from you and your myriad of books. I really liked the part where you read that 'how could they rewrite a whole century of their history, especially when they could not agree on anything and were in constant civil fights.' What a logical argument!

[mohamed-sril]

Keep going! You're filling a crucial gap using fair and balanced academic discourse.

[rambaq]

Br Paul, you're indeed spending your time where it should be spent. May Allah reward you for he's the all-knowing.

[logicalreasoning]

It’s simple really. If someone says Muhammed didn’t exist, then they need to say that Ali ibn Abu taleb, Hassan, Hussein, Zain Al Abedeen etc.. didn’t exist. That’s a lot of people you need to prove didn’t exist

[hmp]

He exists In our hearts also, may blessings and peace be upon him.

[braderaku]

Paul, this video was very special. I like how you tackle difficult topics like these in a straight forward manner and don't beat around the bush.

[alromaani]

Great content - would love to have a live discussion with you on your approach and objectives if possible. The Muslim community is impressed by your work but we want to know what is next.

[aRsH-aJ]

Xtian missionaries: "Muhammad didn't exist".
Byzantine and Sassanids: "Then whose *companions* brought us to our knees? Are we jokes to you?"

[MohamedAli-fjnb]

Allah blessed you Paul, you taught me what I have never known about Muslim, or the Islam. Despite that I came from Muslim background, what I learned from you built so much about my knowledge of Islam.
Thank you.

[deqadegan]

Just saw a video with this exact title from jay Smith and some ex Muslim couple days ago and I was like , these people are not serious!!!

[mustfaaboassd]

I find it extreme skepticism to just throw away the oral history of a nation

[NickyRomero-pzgn]

peace and blessings be upon our beloved prophet Muhammad 😍😍😍😍😍, i love you i wanna see you

[শাওনমাহমুদ-ধ১চ]

love and respect to our beloved prophet Muhammad (SAW)

[ahmadduhir]

Muhammad PBUH was indeed a mighty messenger of Allah, Great presentation Br. Paul may Allah protect you and Guide us all to his true Path.

[alib]

Paul you have my utmost respect for your academic integrity! 🙂

[mohammadsaminirtisum]

Paul i want you to think just how much sadaqa jariah(voluntary charity) good deeds you are getting thro the good information you are relaying to all of us. Inshallah bro your scales will be heavy with many good deeds and our prayers for you on the day of judgement.

[khalidbinwaleed]

Thank you so so much for this video brother Paul.You are Awesome👍.You made this video on my request.I m very thankful to you.May Allah give give you paradise ameen🤲🏻

[Colby_-_IRL_and_title_fights]

Western historian: "Muhammad appears to be very important to Islam indeed"

This is the point we're at with these people.