GMC Sierra 1500 vs Ford F150 Lariat, Two Owners Compare

The Full Octane Garage, and our good friend Robert, compare the GMC 1500 and the Ford F150. The two owners swapped trucks for a everyday drive comparison. Stayed tuned and see how they matched up!

[Fulloctanegarage]

Hey guys! Thanks for watching! Which truck did you pick? Leave us a comment below!
Sorry about the airplane noise... somethings are just out of our control....

[stormrider]

Don't think you can go wrong with any of the newer trucks. Watched this video and bought a gmc all terrain edition. My last truck was a Ford F-150 lariat. Absolutely love my gmc. Very happy with it.

[bradhanna]

This is one of the most helpful reviews/comparisons I have seen. You talked about what normal guys care about. I appreciate the candor of all. Thanks!

[georgeforall]

Both are beautiful trucks. If I drove a lot with the family or with other people I'd pick the Ford, but since I drive alone most of the time I think I'd go with the GMC. Also there are so many F-150s on the road that the GMC's looks are a bit more refreshing. But, again, both are very nice!

[sosumya]

My grandfather worked for GM for 35 years, I have owned Siera, Silverado, S-10, and Sonoma, and many other GM products, I recently bought a '16 F-150 XLT 2.7TT V6 and it has been the best, most equipped truck I have owned and your video solidified my purchase. The passenger comforts were dead on and my MPG, I get 20 City and have done upwards of 28-29 at times, but lifetime of 7, 800 miles is 20.4MPG . I cannot complain about that.

[gilbertojimenez]

Guys i really enjoyed the video, both beautiful trucks, I recently bought a 2017 Chevy Silverado which is similar to the GMC and really loved the interior of my truck untill a week a ago i got into a horrible accident and it was considered a total loss, lost my beautiful truck not even 1000 miles on it, now it was not gas friendly it could not go a week with out having to fill up the tank. My dad recently bought a 2018 f150 and the interior feels a lot more roomier and it drives smother, also he says he gets really good gas mileage on it I'm thinking on going with a ford f150 this year, really like how the ford has the push to start, front and rear camera, the tailgate release button on the key fob, lights in the bed and the huge sunroof, I am a Chevy guy since my company has over 25 chevys but I got to give it to ford there is so much more on the trucks, but I will always love Chevrolet for saving mine and my daughters life

[lifeinmotionoutdoorchannel]

I’ve always been a Ford guy but I think GM really nailed their styling inside and outside on this generation. I’m going with a GMC this time since I’ve only owned Fords. Great video!

[BakStrap]

Nice comparison. I just got a 2015 GMC crew because my family outgrew my '01 extended cab. Hey I've always been a GM guy and the deal was right. That being said, I have noticed the same things you guys found, Ford has some pretty nice trucks as well, with some cool features and improvements that I wish GM would offer. But I absolutely love the car-like ride of our
GMC. The fuel economy is pretty impressive when not towing. Add a camper and honestly it's not that much better than my '01.

I know "old" trucks don't generate much interest, but i'd love to see a comparison of owner cost (maintenance, repairs, etc.) at 100K, 105K, and 200K miles. That would be the best test for those of us that keep trucks for 10 to 20 years.

[traceymaddox]

I owned 2 F150 4x4, s in the past 3 years. 2016 and 2018. Both were 5.0 V8 crew cabs... but I'm  a GM guy so I had to go with a 2018 GMC Denali Ultimate 4x4 with the 6.2 V8 and I love it. Not bashing Ford owners but I believe I finally have a truck that suits my needs.

[jamesbell]

You guys are honest and not biased. Good video. Just went with a GMC today.

[swampgumpharpy]

I traded my 2016 F150 for my 2017 Silverado. There are pros and cons with both trucks. 

F150
Pros:
1. Ecoboost is peppy, and makes the truck feel light around town
2. Real world fuel economy is very impressive
3. Twin turbos make trailering effortless
4. Center console is set more forward, thus more comfortable
5. Truck is taller from the factory. You naturally sit up higher
6. Styling is sporty and purposeful

Cons

1. Lighter weight makes you feel rough roads more
2. In the shop for warranty repairs all the time (some major... like brakes failing)
3. Interior feels slightly cavernous (opinion)
4. Less standard equipment on mid-trim levels (comparing XLT to LT)

Silverado
Pros:
1. The truck feels heavier and smoother over rough roads and terrain
2. Standard LED headlights on LT models
3. Reliable as hell
4. V8 has balls. It just has balls (can that be a pro?)
5. Interior feels more compact, sporty, and in some ways ergonomic
6. Agressive, wide-stance styling (unfortunately, on a squatty platform)

Cons

1. 5.3 isn't much for trailering. If you pull with your 5.3 and like it, fine; albeit, you should trailer with an ecoboost, and you'll see what everybody's talking about. We're talking 8k Lbs. 
2. Even though the styling is aggressive and wide, it looks squatty and a little like Grandpa's truck straight from the factory (Mods are more of a must on the Silverado than the F150
3. Rattles, rattles, rattles rattles. They're everywhere. (I've fixed all of mine)
4. ... There aren't any more cons for this truck. Fuel economy isn't as good as the EB, but it isn't bad either. I put a 5" lift on mine with 33" Toyo MT's, and it still gets over 16 mpg's consistently. Not bloody bad for a lifted 4x4.

[kwakubomani]

I sold my 2015 F150 XLT with the 302A package, extended fuel tank, and panoramic sunroof. Took the truck on several long trips and it really is a good truck. I went with the V8 and it's nothing like putting the truck in sport mode to pass other vehicles. I'm thinking that I will get another truck next year, but it will be a 2018 XLT or a Tundra (V8 either way).

[carterful]

I haven't driven a ford in years. But I do have a 2016 Denali and mine was in for painting due to a shopping cart. I had a SLT rental and noticed a huge difference in the ride compared to my Denali magnetic suspension control. Even a few of my F150 buddies noticed the roll difference in corners and over bumps

[joseduranjr]

We’ve always had Ford products but lately purchased a GMC Sierra DENALI ULTIMATE truck with the 6.2 and now we love GMC.

[gordonhenwoodsr.]

Good comparison. I just purchased a F150 Limited and really happy with it. I looked at both before my purchase. Some minor issues but overall happy.

[edwingarza]

I like what the gmc owner said it's based on personal preference both trucks are in the same class and awesome

[anthonypayne]

Thanks for the video! I have never considered myself Ford or GM. However I am currently shopping and looking at these two awesome trucks. Your insight and opinions have helped me further my decision.

[privateinfo]

Just bought a new, black 2017 Silverado, crew cab all-star edition Z71 LT short bed and I love it.. gorgeous, sharp truck .. was stickered at 48 and got it for 36 so I'm happy.. Ford wouldn't discount me anywhere NEAR as much, not even half as much, so I went with the Silverado.  Used 2014's on the lot were almost 33 .. so why pay that when the brand new one was a couple grand more and brand new on sale :)

[alanrobison]

Great job guys!! I'm a Ford truck guy pretty much but it was great to see what the 1500 had to offer. Still a Ford truck man after seeing the clip especially knowing that the Ford had two higher levels to go. My only critique would be that I would have liked to see what the Ford fully decked out would produce in the tests. I think it would be a no brainer at that point. Again, I really enjoyed everyone's hard work and I have subscribed!! God Bless you guys!!

[luisbarrera]

Just purchased my first GMC after 3 Ford F-150 in a row.. I really like GMC i think it an amazing truck with a very comfortable ride, extremely quiet cab and great looks, but I do miss the keyless entry on the ignition, and my son hates riding in the back since the GMC is a lot smaller. (leg room) So 3 years from today I may be going back to Ford unless GMC makes a few adjustments.