Top 10 Dark Moments in MLP You Haven't Noticed

My Little Pony is a show for little girls, there is no way dark elements can possibly be there right? Right? You're about to WatchPony and we're counting down our picks for the Top 10 Dark Moments in MLP You've Never Noticed.

[JazzLeeIllustrates]

Discord was turned to stone for a thousand years and was confirmed to be totally aware of himself and his surroundings during that period. I consider that a terrifying state to be in

[dorrin]

"You can't have a nightmare if you never dream."

That might be the most terrifying thing I've ever heard...

[galaxyckk]

"Twilight DIED and was reborn an Alicorn"
*Jaw drops to the earth core*

[stonks]

Fluttershy: "I'd like to be a tree."

[CilanSteele]

"Zecora most likely died after that blast"
*shows her getting up immediately after*

[b.a.t.]

"MLP is a show for little girls"
Bronies: am I a joke to you?

[littlevega]

“My little pony is a show for little girls”

**The entire MLP community, including little boys, grown men, and grown women**

*Debatable*

[DoctorTex]

Cannibal.
Noun.
An animal that feeds on the flesh of its own species.
Last time I checked, pigs aren't ponies.

[Dark_Tale]

Got to give an honerable mention to the fate of the Mean Six. Yes they were originally just magical clones but they were still living, sentient creatures with a mind of their own. And they got melted back into chunks of wood by the tree of harmony. No one other than Chrysalis even knew of their existence.

[raaaaaaat]

*"my little pony is a show for little girls"*
Said a grown up man who works for this channel


how is this comment not deleted yet jfc

[pearlescen]

Wow I never realized that Trixies act was like a suicide.
Also the background music is epic

[drshabyek]

10:42
“We see many trees in the beginning of the episode, and there’s no telling how many of them used to be ponies.”
That line scared me for life...(sorry for spoilers :p)

[kimmy]

Fluttershy: *gets swamp fever, a sickness that makes you turn into a tree*
Fluttershy in earlier season: "I'd like to be a tree."
Edit: WHY DOES THIS HAVE SO MANY LIKES GUYS STOP LIKING IT THIS IS CRINGE

[cringeypuma]

"Fluttershy killed a changeling"

The changeling continued flying..
He didnt die..

[starsapphire]

Luna's nightmare in "A Royal Problem" when her teeth fell out. Easily one of the creepiest things I've seen, not only in the show, but in anything animated.

[jensinahansen]

my top list of darkest mlp in cannon
1. Swamp fever (a contagious plague)
2. Mirror pool (only one may live hopefully it's not the real you)
3. Tantabus (fear into peoples minds)
4. Tartrus (hellish place maybe even torture (they put a pg rating for it but clearly it's a kids show however, Tartrus adult version is much more in depth and is much far scary)
5. Elements of harmony (one of the mlp most greatest weapon of all time, sending luna to the moon, turn discord into stone, murdering king sombra (he did scream in pain) Elements of harmony is a weapon a mass destruction weapon. depending on the wielder could have the darkest op magic in history of mlp.

twilight killed sombra this means twilight sparkle is the new kira from death note.

[Minkiesha]

Do You remember That Episode when Rainbow Dash broke her wing and was in a hospital? Yeah...well....And when she was returning for the book, you could see a pony with a cancer. And In the Next Episode, when CMC were singing (hearts and hooves Day) you can see the funeral....

[kenniikarkalicious]

Who knew a show with talking unicorns and baby dragons could warrant a top 10 darkest moments. I love how the writers aren't afraid of having more macabre themes, without going too overwhelmingly horrid for the kids.

[World_Theory]

I still remember being shocked when I first saw the Too Many Pinkies episode. These Pinkie Pie clones/copies are shown to be able to think and speak; and to me, that means there're alive, even if you were to assume their body was composed of ‘magical energy’ or something like that, instead of biology as we know it. (Coincidentally, this also places most version of “vampire” or similar “undead”, firmly in the category of “living”, for me.) Meaning that what Twilight was doing, is highly suspect, morally. And on top of that, I want to point to the reason *why* Twilight needed to use a test to separate the ‘real’ Pinkie from the others. This says to me, that the abominable spell she used to get rid the the excess Pinkies, could have harmed or outright killed the ‘real’ Pinkie if she were hit. And this brings me to the next part… How is the ability to stare at a wall, meant to test for essential ‘Pinkie-ness’? The only answer I can think of, is that it can't.

And so, we arrive at the True Horror… Did Twilight unilaterally decide that Pinkie and the extras were identical? Did she come to the conclusion, in that strange, obsessive mind of hers, that the world should only have one Pinkie Pie? Did she set up the “test” as a ruse, to “prove” that she had the right Pinkie in the end, as a bit of theater, while she just outright murders enough copies of her friend, that there is only one left? Did she kill the Pinkie Pie Prime, the original? And how does this reflect on the psychology of the mind that decided on this course of action?

Is Pinkie really the “crazy one” of the bunch, or is she outshone by another?

[shivikachintanippu]

“My little pony is a show for little girls”
Me: Ehem, People.