I Ranked Every Red Dead Redemption 1 Towns From Worst To Best

NONE OF THIS FOOTAGE IS MY OWN.
@NathanGraham @BasementGamerBros @RedDeadReplay

Today, I am going to rank every Red Dead Redemption 2 in a tierlist, starting from the worst chapters, and going all the way to the best chapters.

This is just my opinion, so put yours in the comments and let's debate!

[Pickaxe_Muderer]

Armadillo in last place hurts a little. That’s literally my favorite town out of all towns in both games

[chiefofficerhenrywilde]

Rank every protagonist outfit including jack

[SpeedDemon]

McFarlenes ranch is my favourite. I love the vibe of it and it’s really nice to just relax and walk around taking in the sites. I also like how it is involved in the story obviously being the place John wakes up at after being shot by Bill Williamson and his gang members. Bonnie is a welcoming and kind person who doesn’t judge John for the decisions he made. You can tell she begins to have feelings for John which collapses when John mentions he is already married. Regardless the two develop a friendship.

[Cheez_Doodlezz]

I love hanging around Chuparosa idk why i just gives me the mexico western vibe idk i love being there

[sonicthelegend]

Armadillo is one of my favorites in my opinion

[tazinboor]

Bonnie Macfarlene’s Dad’s name is Drew Macfarlene.

[Icy_Cream]

My Rank (rdr1+rdr2):

Obs¹: I considered only places that have two or more somekind of atcvities/interactions, that are not linked to main story or stranger missions. On this way, Dutch's gang camps, and also the gang hideouts through the map were all disconsidered.

Obs²: To Towns/Settlements that had different versions on both games, i considered to put only the ones that i like the most.

26 - Benedict Point (rdr1)
25 - Wallace Station
24 - Plainview (rdr1)
23 - Lagras
22 - Ridgewood Farm (rdr1)
21 - Flatneck Station
20 - El Matadero (rdr1)
19 - Las Hermanas (rdr1)
18 - Annesburg
17 - Emerald Ranch/Station
16 - Rathskeller Fork (rdr1)
15 - Casa Madrugada (rdr1)
14 - Strawberry
13 - Manzanita Post (rdr1)
12 - Mcfarlane Ranch (rdr1)
11 - Beecher' Hope (rdr2)
10 - Van Horn
09 - Thieves Landing (rdr1)
08 - Tumbleweed (rdr2)
07 - Escalera (rdr1)
06 - Rhodes
05 - Chuparosa (rdr1)
04 - Saint Denis
03 - Armadillo (rdr1)
02 - Valentine
01 - Black Water (rdr1)

[GabeGettinRich]

I think Thieves Landing was where I’d have preferred to be .

[tazinboor]

WHOO! First Red Dead Redemption 1 video!

[tazinboor]

I’m waiting for the moment you upload your next video tonight, because I put your videos in Hadzy and I saw that you usually upload your recent videos later in the day.

[silverdust]

I really wish that Tumbleweed was an actual town in rdr1

[Verdun]

Armadillo and Chuparosa were my favorite.

[tazinboor]

What we’re the problems with the video that forced you to take it down for a bit?

[bilalturkan]

They need to do a remake of this if they don’t come up with a RDR3

[tazinboor]

Rank Every Mission in this game please!
My top 3 might be
3. And The Truth Will Set You Free
2. The Last Enemy That Shall Be Destroyed
1. The Assault On Fort Mercer

[tazinboor]

Everybody Gunslinga’ til he puts Armadillo at last.

I’m kidding, I’m fine with it, but I thought I was funny with Gunslinga’ instead of Gangsta’.

[robertmackey]

Day 2 for asking a Red Dead revolver an undead nightmare villains ranked

[frizzyrascal]

MacFarlanes Ranch is a cool town but above Thieves Landing and Armadillo? lol

[ItsBuuild]

Armadillo is does not deserve the hate bro

[mnchris]

I want to ask you guys your opinions: I want to play RDR1 on my PS4. Is it worth buying? I have never played it before and I am eager to buy it (physical copy).