If GOD Is SINLESS, Then Did He CREATE Sin?

What if sin wasn’t just a byproduct of human rebellion but an integral part of God’s design from the start? In this thought-provoking exploration, we dive deep into the story of Adam and Eve, the origins of sin, and the true role of free will. Could sin have been inevitable, part of the divine plan to push humanity toward growth, understanding, and moral consciousness? We examine key biblical passages, like Isaiah 45:7, and challenge the traditional views of sin, the serpent, and the fall of mankind. Was the “fall” actually the first step toward enlightenment?

As we unravel the complexities of sin, free will, and God's omniscience, we raise critical questions: Was God responsible for sin, or was it humanity’s inevitable choice? And what role does Satan truly play? This deep dive takes you beyond the surface to consider the possibility that sin is a necessary tension—one that pushes us to grow, evolve, and understand the world in a way that wouldn't have been possible in a sinless paradise. Join the conversation and decide for yourself if sin was part of a grander design.

#sin #adamandeve #fallofman #biblicaltruth #serpent #godandfreewill #isaiah457 #satan #freewillandchoice #moralgrowth #divineplan #originalsin #christianphilosophy #goodandevil #temptation #genesisstory #theology

[-pox]

Religion creates a problem (sin) and offers a solution (God). Humans stay in line. Easy.

[Bryan-nf]

Ignorance is humanity's largest problem not sin. I can point out a few reasons why.

[markellwilliams]

I rather have been safe, ignorant and stagnant. How would I have known I was ignorant, unsafe and stagnant?

[reggiestewart]

I am very disappointed. I thought I was the only one that believed and understood this. I am writing a book on this very topic. I am deliberately trying to limit my exposure to others ideas and opinions, so that I can always have my personal thoughts not be influenced by others. Have you somehow gotten access to my transcripts. However, I am aware that if anyone is a critical thinker, they will logically come to the same conclusion. I been writing my book for more than twenty years. I work a full time job, so it is difficult for me to write because I need free time to research, investigate, and brainstorm my thoughts. But, hopefully sometime in the near future I will delve in with zeal and passion to get it completed. I hope you will read it.

[JustinWilliams-qqri]

cause he want us to over come sin ... we have power within us ... choice

[enigmoxical]

God is *creating* (present tense) mankind in His image. This is why we are here. But before that image can be completed, we must possess a knowledge of good and evil (Genesis 3:22). So yes, everything is going according to plan. This man understood this..
"God knew that men would sin in all ways, but permitted this result to come to pass, knowing that it would ultimately be for their advantage. For since God created man when he did not exist, and made him ruler of so extended a system, and offered so great blessings for his enjoyment, it was impossible that He should have not prevented the entrance of sin if He had not known that it would be ultimately for his advantage. Therefore God divided the creation into two states, the present and the future. In the latter He will bring all to immortality and immutability. In the former He gives us over to death and mutability. For if He had made us at first immortal and immutable, we should not have differed from irrational animals, who do not understand the peculiar characteristics by which they are distinguished. For if we had been ignorant of mutability we could not have understood the good of immutability. Ignorant of death, we could not have known the true worth of immortality. Ignorant of corruption, we could not have properly valued incorruption. Ignorant of the burden of sinful passions, we could not have duly exulted in freedom from such passions. In a word, ignorant of an experiment of evils, we should not have been able properly to understand the opposite forms of good." - Theodorus of Mopsuestia (350-428 AD)

[gatewaytobeing]

Sin simply means "missing the mark." That's equal to being human. We try, we make mistakes, we mess up, we make some poor choices, often because we didn't have the knowledge or experience to choose differently. There's no human that can escape these very human doings and beings. Try, try again. That's the game.

[noeinfantejr]

Now I understand, thank you for explaining I can see now something beautiful could I have learned, thank you

[Magnus-vx]

There can't be any Light without Darkness and no Good without Evil, the important thing is the choices we make, what side are you on?

[Zzjb]

The Lord commanded Adam in Eden, “Of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat;” “for in the day that thou eatest thereof, thou shalt surely die.” But another voice was heard saying, “Ye shall not surely die.” This strange voice tested Adam and Eve, and proved their loyalty. They had an opportunity to show whether they would be obedient to God, or would disregard his word, and accept that of the deceiver who came to destroy them. The Lord did not prove Adam and Eve in a large matter. The test given them was the smallest that could have been devised ST October 29, 1885, par. 14

[kennethmcdade]

the serpent wasnt a snake. he didnt become a snake until god cursed him making him to be the lowest of the low and crawl upon his belly from then on

[pushthebutton]

I believe that the God of this Bible created our bodies and put us into these bodies simply for our worship of it. Its own vanity. Why is it so important for us to reproduce? The most important thing we can do is pray, obey and be fruitful and multiply. It seems to me he wants a almost infinite amount of people to worship it. Any being that wants that just to be worshiped as the Bible say prostrate thyself before the Lord and gaze upon me, which is something that is impossible. The idea of something that just want you to worship it and create more people to worship It is nothing that I want to be a part of

[denniseijs]

If God didn't make it, where did it come from?
And is nakedness evil? Why? They noticed their, nakedness and covert themselves. Now that is shame, not wisdom or knowledge. They hid from God, that is, fear. So the fruit of shame and fear.

[ianmoise]

You can see it's in Deuteronomy 30 a command the choice of God is to do right. Man choice is to rebel.

[Tiuut]

Everybody people got choice to whom to listen.as Our Father in heaven got a choose to human their life will change to something better.😊❤and who is not picked up from god.😊❤will be darkness.be cause Our Father in heaven show me what could be happent😊❤but believing into god is matter.😊❤

[Zzjb]

Angels on probation had been deceived by Satan, and had been led on by him in the great rebellion in Heaven against Christ. They failed to endure the test brought to bear upon them, and they fell. Adam was then created in the image of God and placed upon probation. He had a perfectly developed organism. All his faculties were harmonious. In all his emotions, words, and actions, there was a perfect conformity to the will of his Maker. After God had made every provision for the happiness of man, and had supplied his every want, he tested his loyalty. If the holy pair should be obedient, the race would, after a time, be made equal to the angels. As Adam and Eve failed to bear this test, Christ proposed to become a voluntary offering for man. 2Red 15.2

[sandrabond-wvok]

He was discontent. Life was too good. He thought, let me go, and make sin. That will make things entertaining. Satan obliged him.

[Zzjb]

When God placed Adam in Eden, He told him that he might eat of the fruit of every tree in the garden save one, the tree of knowledge of good and evil. Thus Adam's obedience was to be tested. God left him free to obey or disobey. He could have held him back from touching the forbidden fruit, but had He done this, Satan would have been sustained in saying that God's rule was arbitrary. Adam was left perfectly free. RH September 24, 1901, par. 5

[ianmoise]

Deuteronomy 30  in that I command thee this day to love the Lord thy God, to walk in His ways, and to keep His commandments and His statutes and His judgments, that thou mayest live and multiply; and the Lord thy God shall bless thee in the land whither thou goest to possess it.

17 But if thine heart turn away so that thou wilt not hear, but shalt be drawn away and worship other gods and serve them,

18 I declare unto you this day that ye shall surely perish, and that ye shall not prolong your days upon the land whither thou passest over the Jordan to go to possess it.

19 I call heaven and earth to record this day against you that I have set before you life and death, blessing and cursing. Therefore choose life, that both thou and thy seed may live,

20 that thou mayest love the Lord thy God, and that thou mayest obey His voice, and that thou mayest cleave unto Him; for He is thy life and the length of thy days, that thou mayest dwell in the land which the Lord swore unto thy fathers, to Abraham, to Isaac, and to Jacob, to give them.”

[Universalwisdomknowledge]

The demiurge established the positive and negative polarities of creation and destruction in the material universe and is the ruler of good and evil. The person who pretends to be God can also be the devil.