EVERYTHING This Muslim Ali Dawah Says Is EMBARRASSING

In this video, we dive deep into a philosophical debate sparked by Ali Dawah’s appearance on the Towards Eternity podcast, where he challenges the notion that infinite time leads to infinite possibilities. Using examples like creating a Ferrari or a dessert (sütlaç) out of nothing, Ali argues that no matter how much time passes, specific outcomes won't occur without the necessary components. But is this argument a valid critique of the atheist position, or is it a misunderstanding of the concept of probability and possibility?

--

References:

[frankpulmanns]

Empirical data would suggest it doesn't take infinite time to get a Ferrari. It takes about 13.8 billion years.

[Maya_Ruinz]

“Saying it with confidence” that is pretty much the start of every cult to ever exist…

[glennmcdonnell]

Given an omnipotent God is infinitely more complicated and organised than a Ferrari, what is the probability such a God comes to existence by chance? In the beginning? Before anything else? Fully formed? Conscious? Intelligent? Emotional? Capable of conceiving and constructing a universe in which life can exist?

[Wooderz]

As long as the probability of an event isn't Zero, if time is infinite, the likelihood of any particular event is 1 every time.

I don't think these people understand the scale of Infinity, or more likely, they do understand and are being deliberately misleading.

[itsirrelephantman]

Even the little joke about his sutlac is part of the performance, a little light hearted distraction from the wool he's trying to pull over your eyes.

[jacobh]

Can infinite time exist without infinite space? Why are we moving the goalposts so far? We started with an infinite premise and ended up talking about a drinking glass!

[explodingtiger]

What part of reality/cosmos is analogous to the empty glass? The fact is that the cosmos does contain the contents necessary to make a Ferrari, a universe or a Turkish dish.

[jontalbot]

I would imagine the reason he is so convincing is because he has first convinced himself and the audience appreciate it because almost none if them have ever thought about these things so it’s nice to have them introduced and then demolished in a way consistent with their pre- existing beliefs.

[CapsAdmin]

If you roll a 6 sided dice an infinite amount of times, you will never get 7.
However if you roll a billion sided dice an infinite amount of time, you will get infinite 7's.

[hansj]

Dawah is so dishonest, arrogant and condescending it's nauseating.

[marcsunborn]

Wait, he is absolutely wrong, God could easily manifest the appropriate amount of Sütlac inside that glass! How could he miss that, I'm shocked!

[ryidnqc]

Oh man, seeing atheist in their echo chamber here is so funny. The argument is you can't have something out of nothing, there must be "ingredient" for the universe to exist. Not only that, the "law of nature" needs to be fine-tuned for this life to exist.

[PatrickWDunne]

Reminder that Ali doesn't let his own wife speak on camera and thinks apostasy should be punished by death.

[GodsCosmicBollock]

Having Ali Dawah proselytise for you must like hiring Alan Partridge to run your PR campaign.

[YouTubeman-derw]

I swear I see issues with audio sync all the time on this channel. I reload the page 4 times the audio comes through fine but it's not even close to linked up to the video

[niclash]

The apologist counter; "Given infinite time --> God is a certainty."

[sebben]

Well actually, the glass is not empty. It is in fact filled with air☝️🤓

[fullyawakened]

He's not only wrong about straw-manning, he's wrong even if his strawman was true! Given infinite time, a Ferrari actually would pop into existence out of nothingness, using the same logic as the concept of Boltzmann brains.

[romulanwang]

Yes, there is a zero change of the glass turning into a ferrari because there are different numbers of atoms in the glass and ferrari, and enrgy and momentum are conserved, and there is no mechanism for this to take place. The analogy of the universe, is nonsensical because we DON'T KNOW what the mechanism was, but we observe that the universe exists, so there MUST have been a mechanism. If we has ACTUALLY OBSERVED the glass change to a ferrari, THEN we could have concluded that there WAS a mechanism.

[genghisdingus]

Crazy how Ali Dawah not only looks evil but is evil.