PORSCHE CAYMAN VS AUDI TT RS VS BMW Z4 VS JAGUAR F-TYPE - The FULL Challenge | Fifth Gear

#FIFTHGEAR #PORSCHECAYMAN

[sharg]

These "elimination" tests are terrible. It's just to put the tests in the order you want to get the chosen result. Only way you can't get a specific car to win is that it's worst in all categories.

Not to mention the "one off" chance, just look at the mediocre launch of the Cayman.
Do it properly like use best out of three runs with each car.

[lesplaatjies]

Wait, how do you eliminate a track car through a road test then have a track showdown after that!! 🤔

[JerrySalamante]

The test is a HUGE disservice to Jaguar & Porsche. Jaguar would've won On-road Comfort test, BUT was eliminated too early. Porsche would've won Race Track test, BUT was eliminated too early. (The "T" stands for Track; of course it would lose the comfort test!) IMO, this video competition has zero validity.

[Adi-S]

Are you kidding me? You use a cell phone for taking the time? And then you talk about 10th of seconds?
I think that Fifth Gear should be able to afford a Racelogic V-Box or similar.
Those reviews are just worthless!

[kozootsuka]

If you bring in BMW M40 and Audi TTRS, why do you compare them against the normal 718 Cayman? You should have compared them against 718 Cayman S or GTS.
This is a very invalid test👎

[dtmenace]

“Track car showdown” - eliminates track cars first...?

[stevegoomas]

If they tested the BMW M40i American version 382 HP it probably would have won the track test as well. Amazing car.

[shaunmcinnis]

Normally I wouldn't agree with this test, but because I just bought the z4 M40i..I will.. Awesome car.

[longtailgt]

I never liked these "elimination" tests. There should be a points system for each test and whichever car gets the most total points at the end should be the winner.

[Chris-njmr]

Tiff would have had that Z4 sideways the whole lap then slammed the TT for understeer. I miss Tiff

[glennmiller]

Looks/Design/Heritage - F-Type
Handling/performance/prestige - Cayman
Nice to drive/sporty/fun - BMW
Good for the price/Technically efficient/kind of practical - Audi

[r.mtn.]

Regardless of your dubious testing protocols and conclusions, I prefer the Jag experience over all the others, so I bought one

[Chris-njmr]

12:00 "ohh ya fighter!"
Classic Plato 😂

[ndivhuwomphaphuli]

Would it not be best to subject all vehicles to the same tests and the give the best overall combined score? The Jag, while not fast in a straight line could have fared better on a road test. Same for the Porsche, this could maybe have done better on a track.

[ayushmankar]

Where is Mercedes SL43 AMG & Lexus RCF ?

[crstothard]

These ain't the same without Tiff...

[OverlandTT]

I ask again - why isn't Tiff on this! He is entertaining and delivers true feel in his journalism!

[edarcuri]

3 nice looking German cars. As good as they looked, the F type blew them away! For my money: Jaguar.

[ptgnishu]

the tt rs was a serious contender in the group, so the final outcome is well deserved, but it's laughable how they chose the track focused cayman t and eliminate it on a road comfy test!

[joeybrooks]

You need to use the F-Type S or R in this comparison. Not the base 4 pot.