How does F1 22 compare to AMS 2 & Assetto Corsa?

#f122 #f1 #ams2 #assettocorsa #simracing

It's launch week for the new official F1 22 game, so I thought I'd do a comparison of how the new title's cars stack up against those in Assetto Corsa and AMS 2. Let's get into it!

Enjoying the content? There are loads of ways you can say thanks and support me to bring even more to the channel!!

Join La Broca Paddock Club to get access to channel badges, emojis, early access and behind the scenes action:

And remember if you do enjoy the video, you can leave a like and comment on the video to help more people find it too.

[Ben_LaBroca]

Hey everyone, the RSS Formula Hybrid 2022 is now out too for Assetto Corsa. Early impressions are it's an excellent car, and there isn't much to choose between it and the VRC Formula Alpha in my opinion. If anything the RSS car is a bit more forgiving and immediately accessible. But there's so much depth to these cars that is just an initial reflection. Check it out if you're interested!

[notthefia]

5:34 Porpoising actually can be simulated in F22 or at least was simulated by codies but they chose to disable the feature and gave the response of, because whilst it was possible, the player would ultimately get bored and fustrated with it and would want to turn it off so it’s a waste putting all that effort in for it eventually to be turned off, plus it’s something that’s not actually meant to be there in real life and the teams/ FIA are doing the absolute most they can to get rid of it so why would you want it in the game when it’ll probably be gone at the end of the season. The final reason was to do with the career mode upgrades and what team you drive for, porpoising would either be there for the long run and would be a pain in the ass to fix, or gone instantly depending on how you chose to upgrade around it or just straight up fix it, plus some of the upgrades might not even work at all and would just make the car worse and the player more annoyed. Personally I’d want the challenge of having to upgrade around it, or really having to dial in the set up for it, things going wrong and taking time

[shadowwsk]

I love the porpoising in the vrc car because it gives me a challenge in making a fast setup while not porpoise to a level that is undrivable. It brings a whole new depth to setup works and it makes it more rewarding to learn how porpoising works in the game.

[CrossFieldz]

For AMS2, you can see extreme porpoising with wet tires. Try it

[GSSimRacing]

I done a vid comparing F1 22 to AMS2. To be honest, I found very little similarities between the two. The F1 22 version was very numb, FFB was terrible and no real useable detail through the wheel (Fanatec DD2). I also found oversteer in F1 22 quite random, and you didn't know you had it until you could visually see the car starting to slip. In all cases, in order to catch it, the answer was to upshift. AMS2 by comparison was very engaging. It actually felt like driving a car. It was way more immersive from a driving perspective. The FFB was in a different league entirely.

[rubenvanalphen]

You should do this comparison again next month with the 1.4 update for ams 2. They have confirmed it for next month, and it will have massive improments to the tire model and just the general physics

[Joe]

If Asseto Corsa VRC has the most demanding physical experience and requires more time, effort and dedication to master as opposed to the plug-in and play versions, then by definition, VRC does it best because I am positive that real F1 cars require exactly that.

[vickolous]

in a podcast thing that codemasters did with david greco (handling designer for the f1 games) he did say that porpoising is possible in f1 22, but they specifically changed the physics to stop the aero stalling under the diffuser at higher speed to prevent it. no way of telling if thats true, or just an excuse for the game engine not being sophisticated enough to simulate it.

[Ben_LaBroca]

Thanks for watching! Let me know what you think of these cars and what else if anything you’d like to see from F1 22!

[googlreviews]

Official F1 2022 feels most Arcade like from where I am sitting 😉

[lupf]

The formula Ultimate Gen. 2 in AMS 2 is so much fun. Since weeks i drive nothing else :)

[simracingwithhandicap]

Great comparison! Actually I like the ACFL F1 cars for Assetto Corsa the most. That mod is expensive but they exactly recreated all 10 cars and liveries and they drive amazing. They also have settings for drivetrain in the setup which I think the VRC is missing.

[cavemanindustries]

For Assetto Corsa you need:

1. Content Manager

2. Custom shaders patch

3. Sol

4. Vrc or RSS F1 car

Lots of tutorials and super easy.

[jonsingleton]

Has to be difficult and realistic. That's why I only race modified AC. Sounds like you were saying AC is the best from a simulator perspective. And I have this car. I'll be buying the RSS next but the VRC is properly engaging and a massive challenge physically, especially in VR and with motion! Exactly how it should be!

[milkovivaldi]

3:10 Automobilista has steering wheel closer therefore we can’t see all tyres, it depends by camera settings or sim?

[flipss]

5:37 The devs told in an Interview with Alex Gillon that they purposefully decided to remove porpoising from the game.

[Tminus]

I'm eagerly awaiting the Final f1 2022 mod from RSS. It should come out soon

[VR_RD]

I recently made the switch from official F1 title to AMS2 and I love it !!!

[detonator]

I've played them all: iRacing, AC, rf2, Automobilista... but ASR Forumula AC mod (1992) still provides me the most enjoyable F1 racing. It feels incredibly good.

Codemasters games are really enjouyable but they're not on the same planet with AC when it comes to physics and force feedback.

[doggo]

Agreed as you mentioned it, f1 22 is missing ffb feeling for me it's hard to estimate the limit of traction without doing it for couple of laps imo