“She’s Lying, She’s Truthful Or Has A Disorder” Baby Reindeer Interview Verdict

Fiona Harvey's interview with Piers Morgan has created shockwaves across the globe, as the 'real' Martha from hit Netflix show Baby Reindeer claims she never stalked show creator Richard Gadd and that glaring falsehoods have been presented as truth, even leading to death threats being made against her.

Piers and his panel; Piers Morgan Uncensored contributor Esther Krakue, lawyers Paula Rhone-Adrien and Mark Geragos, psychologist Dr Drew and Will Jordan, AKA The Critical Drinker dissect the controversial interview, discussing whether Fiona can be trusted and considering the possibility that Netflix has opened itself up to a legal quagmire.

00.00 - Piers Morgan's verdict on his interview with Fiona
05:20 - Paula’s reaction
08:30 - Is Baby Reindeer true?
11:26 - Does Fiona have a legal case?
16:09 - Dr Drew on stalkers
20:12 - Was Fiona ever ‘convicted’?
23:57 - Duty of care
28:45 - Is Richard Gadd a reliable witness?
31:38 - Should Piers have done the interview?

Subscribe to stay up-to-date on all Uncensored content.

Follow Piers Morgan Uncensored on:

Follow Piers Morgan on:

#babyreindeer #fionaharvey #piersmorgan #interview #debate

[PiersMorganUncensored]

Vote for Piers Morgan as Best Presenter in this year's TRIC Awards!

[flightcomputer]

Fiona:
"I don't know him"
"I don't know where he lives"
"I never sent him any letters"
"I sent one letter to where he lives"
"The behaviour of this woman is nothing like me. I recognised it was me he was referencing in the stage show"
"I never sent him any emails."
"I sent him 5 or 6 emails"
"I sent him 8 -10 emails"
"I never had his number"
"I left him one voicemail"
"I like to keep 6 different phones for no reason"
"I was top of my class at nearly everything because I have a photographic memory"
"I can't remember what grades I got for my law degree. I did alright. Not top of my class or anything"

Piers:
"She's clearly very intelligent and has done a great job defending herself"

[dammitjim]

In interviews, Richard Gadd has said emphatically that the "real" Martha did NOT spend any time in jail. That part in the series was fictionalized. He felt sorry for her so did not pursue her to be imprisoned, just a restraining order. Why this is constantly brought up is beyond me.

[KarmaKingttt]

Can we acknowledge how they glossed over the fact that she bombarded a daily mail reporter with 50 calls within a few hours?? That doesn’t ring any alarm??

[telisaking]

The stalker getting stalked by the world is the irony I never knew I needed.

[Edfj]

It literally says at the end of the episode “this program is based on real events: however certain characters, names, incidents, locations, and dialogue have been fictionalized for dramatic purposes”

[annknows]

Why are we acting like we don't understand the difference between a dramatized true story vs hard hitting journalistic documentary? This isn't national geographic.

[rachelfox]

I wish Piers would let his guests on the panel speak more. It’s wild that he has 5 people there and when they begin to speak he interrupts them before they finish a thought.

[brandygiles]

How can she sue for defamation? She says she doesn’t look like the actress, she says she didn’t send all those emails, Netflix never gave her name. She can’t prove the story is about her.

[dougdougw]

"She's lying, or truthful, or has a disorder..." Brilliant insights, guys.

[saima.nijhum]

I love how Piers invites guests for their opinions and DOESN’T LET THEM TALK.

[wendyrichardson]

Fiona Harvey outed herself not Netflix. Richard Gadd has said emphatically that she didn't go to jail because he felt sorry for her. It literally says at the end of each episode it says “this program is based on real events: however certain characters, names, incidents, locations, and dialogue have been fictionalized for dramatic purposes.” Netflix should now do Martha's story.

[bassoonlim]

PIers, with all due respect, I want to hear your panel more. Stop cutting them off and interrupting them

[LisaFerguson-lwil]

I looked for her under her name Fiona Muir-harvey. She caused so much trauma to Scottish members of parliament and their families, all involved had to have security devices. She was fired from a Legal Firm after only a few weeks and went on to terrorise the employers.
I think she is very dangerous.

[adamdrakestudio]

If you think about how the actress got so good at impersonating Fiona, she probably had a lot of material to go off, i.e. a shitload of voicemails.

[tattedchick]

Bring on his ex girlfriend, her mother, his mother, his father and Terri. They all allegedly dealt with her too. You don't just have to hear from Richard Gadd. You can hear from those around him. She may have went to a mental facility not jail and thus they could have sealed the records.

[ClaudiaYorkPetruny-bcpg]

Piers! They didn’t “hire” an actress with the same speech and cadence as real-life stalker. It’s called acting!

[robiyaMir-wd]

I am shocked that no one is talking about that she said that she refused her curtains to be hanged but then she tweeted that she wants her curtains to be hanged

[SafetyPropaganda]

Netflix absolutely bombed the marketing. All they had to say was “based on a true story” and they’d be covered legally. It’s a work of art not a fucking documentary.

[louisroberts]

“This program is based on real events: however certain characters, names, incidents, locations, and dialogue have been fictionalized for dramatic purposes.”

That’s in the closing credits. Job done