Middle-Earth Comparison | Lord of the Rings vs Hobbit | Satisfying Video

Let's compare characters from the Tolkien universe. How tall are Melkor, Frodo, Gandalf, Sauron, Aragorn, Bilbo, Gimli, Saruman, Legolas, Ungalianta, Cave Trolls, Gollum, Balrog, Nazgul, Smaug. See this video for more information.

#sizes #sizecomparison #size #comparison #biggest #satisfying #oddlysatisfying #lotr #hobbit

[greatlegacyoftanks]

Love how it starts with the ring… the only object that changed its own length at will.

[averageman]

Merry and pippin were the tallest hobbits ever thanks to that special ent water

[samalorn]

The tower of Isengard it's called Orthanc.

[hatrungvuong]

ungoliant is many times larger than Melkor, especially when she is enlarged when absorbing light from two magic trees, In addition, you should supplement with Thorondor and Ancalagon. Smaug compared to them is just a doll.

[Epsa_]

To think Tolkien came up with all this in a time of war and depression. His mind was beyond creativity

[joelhutchinson]

This is possibly the worst and most inaccurate Middle Earth size comparison I've ever seen on YouTube.

There has be 0 research done here.

[pepsithecarbo]

I can't be the only one who read the books thinking this is just ridiculously wrong, right?


Edit : After watching things about the rings of power show.... This video isn't that bad. 😬

[jkhristian]

Merry and Pippin were taller than Frodo. They were taller than most hobbits by the end of the quest.

[mairon]

Aragorn being taller than the Nazgûl is so funny.

[kvitravn]

Smaug was definitely not bigger than Ungoliant lol

[robinsteeden]

Many of these heights are just wrong. The Balrog description in Moria is too vague to set a height. In Unfinished Tales I believe a Balrog's height is twice that of the elf fighting him. So maybe 4m, not 8.

[Berserk_]

Aragorn is as Tall as Legolas. And also Ungoliant was Much bigger than Smaug, MUCH bigger lol

[sephirothbahamut]

1.3k people have read the Silmarillion

Balrogs "demons with whips and claws"
Fellbeast "winged Nazgul"
... man... did you do your homework?

[KateJacksonLincoln]

You start straight off with being wrong as you see the ring be various sizes throughout. It changes size to match the potential wearer, hence why it first perfectly on the fingers of Sauron, Ilsildur and Frodo, all of whom are very drastically different sizes, so can’t possibly have the size finger size.

[cush]

Ents 6m ?
Melkor at 23m ?
Where does that come from?

Ents were tree-sized.
Melkor could change his appearance and size. When he descended into Arda he was "as a mountains that wades in the sea"

[Spencer_Thatcher]

Ankalagon the Black got robbed of 1st place here

[underlord]

The nazgûl aren't ghosts. Balrogs weren't all the same size and are also maia. This is just a few of the description problems, but the whole thing is just totally wrong.

[loza]

Saruman and Sauron shouldn’t worry about world domination. They should be hooping 🏀

[Pixis]

"Winged Nazgul" for the fell beasts is not correct. The Nazgul were the Ringwraiths, not the name of their steeds.

[christophlade]

Ungoliant was Not a simply Spider. It was the Avatar of Hunger, able to bind even Morgoth. Oh, and where are the Eagles or Stone Giants?