Peanut Butter Ice Cream Tournament (Taste Test)

In day 3 of our tournament, we're determining the best peanut butter ice cream! GMM # 2569

Click the bell icon so you'll know when we add a new episode!

Want more GMM? Check out these playlists:

Follow Mythical:

Check Out Our Other Mythical Channels:

Intro & Outro Music by Rhett & Link

Get the GMM Set Gear!
(As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases from paid links below)

[NervousDandy]

I was thinking Rhett and Link should have their own Ben and Jerry's flavour... although it would probably just be a pint of straight peanut butter...

[kenlangston]

I wish they had added a fourth category like say cereal so they could have a Final Four.

[davidmoore]

Not having Tillamook Chocolate Peanutbutter is a crime.

[Haldir]

Rhett’s opening monologue’s have been overlooked! They’re awesome! It takes some skill to do that!

[pauletteplatt]

All 3 finalists mixed together would be so good

[Pappagiotto]

how did you not do a standard peanut butter taste test? missed opportunity

[Crunchatize_Me_Senpai]

Those cookie dough bites are delicious but in no world can edible cookie dough be categorized as candy, that round was so botched.

[tazman]

Rhett loves the peanut butter ribbons, yet, Tillamook peanut butter isnt part of this. It has so much peanut butter ribbon in it. 4 Ben and Jerry flavors and one of them isnt really a peanut butter flavor, C'mon. Tillamook and Haagen-daz are the best in my opinion.

[MuffinCandle]

link Definitely smells the ice cream and then looks at Rhett to see if he saw it. 19:17

[matthewdarnell]

It's not reeeses failing the I've cream its breyers, their ice cream just isn't good comparatively to most brands

[jessewalks]

The peanut butter boyz continue their peanut butter takeover

[Mr.February]

When Rhett said, "I've struck gold" with the peanut butter ribbons in the Häagen-Dazs...
I felt that. 4:06

[appleprincess]

Nothing hurts quite like seeing your go-to ice cream getting banished

[bridgetcook]

For once, Link's logic is actually more logical than Rhett's? Love that for him.

[thomziq]

"it's dippable" - this is very important to Link :P:P

[ryanlamont]

Sad to see that Tillamook chocolate peanut butter wasn't a contender 😂

[hannahcollins]

Ordered my triple-signed cookbook this morning!! So excited🎉😊

[coolcado]

PB & J vs PB on celery and PB on a pretzel and other “classic” Peanut butter snacks.

[jessallaround]

Ok, but did you know there are DOUBLE STUFFED Nutter Butters????

They are perfect.

[jhardman]

What does Giant Deborah think about the Little Debbie's placement in this tournament?