2014 Modern vs 2024 Standard

Has Magic been power crept so much that a 2024 Standard deck beats a 2014 Modern deck? Richard battles 2014 Modern Jund against Seth on 2024 Standard Orzhov Midrange to find out!

#MTG #magicthegathering

[Midas_Rex]

Big fan of this series, putting best/meta decks of different magic eras against each other. Really want to see more of this.

[VRanger]

Richard on the thumbnail is how we all feel from the Siege Rhino days XD

[Herintruththelies]

I can't play Magic IRL so I watch a lot of it on YouTube. I must say you guys have done a good job here for several reasons.

You dedicate a lot of screen space to the card in play.

The editor is Johnny-on-the-spot with changing the card in play.

You play kinda slow and read the cards and don't use shortcuts.

You talk about your thought processes and don't just play silent magic.

The sound is good and no annoying music.

Overall a well done production that I wish other Magic YouTubers would learn from.

[YohWolf]

Even if some missed triggers happened and other game errors came out of it. I love that you actually play 60 cards constructed in paper in these videos, please keep them coming.

[AkiVainio]

Rule violation: In game four Seth created a 1/1 from Wedding Announcement, when he should have drawn a card.

[christopherclark]

There is something special about watching actual paper magic vs. digital. Commander clash, and these videos are great content now that they are paper.

[williammarcuse]

Seth putting his adventure cards in a different spot every time he plays one

[andrewric]

I do like this video format. I'd love to see the goldfish crew playtest user-submitted and brewed decks this way when a new sets are about to roll out similar to what SCG used to do. Miss those days.

[victorappleton]

I appreciate all the clarity about all the cards and what they do. It would be easy or even natural to say “it’s Goyf, you all know what’s up” and I appreciate the effort to make things better for newer players

[isalundstrom]

Now I want to see something like 2024 standard vs 2014 modern vs 2004 legacy vs 1994 Type 1 (vintage).

Would be hilarious!

[drowssapism]

51:28 seth you don't make a human because you attacked with two creatures so you would draw a card. don't really know how it would have changed if you seth was one card deeper but down a chump block / removal target from richard

[Tarrandus]

Courser of Kruphix being 10 years old makes me feel old 😢 That card was the new hotness when I started playing.

[surfinggarchomp]

As a magic player who started in late 2019, I really like this series just to see old decks being played.

[espinacasable]

I really like these videos
My favorite series was the banned bracket from some years ago so I'm glad y'all are doing more

[CenJohan]

I know that this is Goldfish so Jund midrange was the inevitable meme pick for “old modern” deck, but I think it would be interesting to use this format to show off other past modern lists. Decks like titan bloom, twin, melira pod, etc.

[imperialcitizen]

This is the best series on your channel. I would LOVE to see more videos in this style, either digital or in paper. It would be great to see broken standards like Darksteel Standard fight against another broken Standard from 10 or 15 years later and see how it plays out. I think one could match up different standard metas from pre fire design like this and get very interesting results. Post fire it all seems like kind of a wash.

[kannanraju]

fantastic production quality - loved the setups and the commentary. More please!

[_claymore]

Nadu v. Hogaak was really cool to see, so I am excited that you make this a series! hope there's more to come, it's really interesting to see the old v. new MTG.
also honestly not surprised to see 2024 standard rip into decade old modern. the power creep is evident from set to set nowadays, so going back a full decade is almost a death sentence.

[jerbearwin]

Preacher of the schism doesn't trigger when you attack planeswalkers. Didn't matter but still

[thedudeable]

More Richard playing Magic! More historical comparisons! This is amazing stuff that truly shows Magic's everchanging history and gameplay that I love from MTGGoldfish!