The Ultimate “Does This Pizza Have Mushrooms?” Challenge

Taylor Tomlinson challenges Taran Killam, Tone Bell, and Jess McKenna to stitch with as many millennial midlife crises as they can. The panelist with the lowest score at the end of the round is eliminated. Later, the remaining panelists have to guess if a slice of pizza has mushrooms on it for the win.



#AfterMidnight #TaylorTomlinson #Comedy #TVShows #Gameshow #Game #tiktok #stitch #millennial #millennials #midlifecrisis #pizza #brainrot

Watch After Midnight with Taylor Tomlinson weeknights at 12:37/11:37c, after The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, on CBS and Paramount Plus.

---
AFTER MIDNIGHT is the smartest show on television about the dumbest things on the internet. With celebrated comedian Taylor Tomlinson at the helm and a panel of guests from the worlds of entertainment, comedy, music and beyond, AFTER MIDNIGHT is a late-night comedy series about what set the internet abuzz that day with a game show feel. AFTER MIDNIGHT airs Monday through Friday, 12:37-1:37 AM, ET/PT on the CBS Television Network and streams live on Paramount+.

[jouneymanwizard]

The real champion here is Vlad not cracking up while people around you have unhinged discussions on pizza composition

[Tonyhouse]

Think I’m gonna miss this show when it’s gone. Thanks for the memories TayTo

[victoriabaker]

I get it that Taylor wants to resume her fulltime standup career, but i wish the show would continue. Its a great venue for finding new comics and actors to love. This group of contestants was really fun. ❤ 😂 😮

[JeffSchall]

Not even a pretense of giving a prize anymore, and on top of it, we didn't get to see the punch! "Foul, " I cry. "FOUL!"

[gweebara]

I love it when a guest makes you truly sad that they were the one eliminated by doing so well in their elimination walk away

[jrbship]

I’m so glad that the game that decides the winner is still so incredibly stupid 😂

[randywoods]

Wait, not even a stage punch from Vlad?... 😕

[nbuehster]

3:16 to 3:33 I joked about this in the video about Elton John, but someone should concat Lin-Manuel Miranda.

After Midnight: The Musical

[Infinitesimal-hoit]

You'll want mushrooms on that sandwich for impact soakage (strangely, that word is not being underlined as a mistake or misspelling).

[Quetzalboatl]

I was imagining the winner getting a noogie the entire time!

[Tonyhouse]

We get a Sklar Bro tomorrow? Sweet! “Daddy!! WHY DID MOMMA LEAVE US DADDY!!”
Best clip of @M ever has the Sklar Bros in it

[emilyviehland]

Would I bring the leftovers home? NOPE! I'm allergic to mushrooms. 😂

[RaffixOW]

Taran Killam asks to role-play his actual role in the TV series "High Potential", did the serie get approved for a 2nd season?

[ZachsMind]

What? No pineapple? I'm a pineapple on pizza man. I don't care about mushrooms.

[barrettpickett]

That knuckle head is scary. Whatever you do don't break character.

[TravisBickle-clnw]

When you combine the terms "mushrooms" and "blotter" in the same segment, there's a "high" chance your writers have been micro-dosing.

[TrueSeanja]

Millennials are just adult forever kids

[mulletforyou]

What do you think the winner did with their knuckle sandwich?

[JDMimeTHEFIRST]

I am spending no time taking care of children and I love it

Saw my mom doing that. No thank you

[oification]

Aw man, dude defaulted to Blair Witch corner with elimination