Who is God? One religion answers this question better than the others. | Big Think

Who is God? One religion answers this question better than the others.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Did God make us in his image, or do we make him in ours? The answer becomes apparent when you ask devoutly religious people to describe their god. Religious scholar Reza Aslan cites a series of studies by cognitive scientist Justin L. Barrett which show that, on paper, the devout tend to score a perfect A for theological knowledge but, in conversation, that theology flies out the window—a god who is omnipresent was just "too busy" to hear a prayer, for example. The more people reveal about how they imagine the divine, the more they describe attributes and biases they happen to possess, what Aslan refers to as divinizing ourselves. "Unconsciously, we can’t help but to imagine God as essentially a divine version of ourselves. When we conceive of God we unconsciously, innately, impose upon God our own personality, our own virtues, our own vices, our own strengths, our own weaknesses. We project upon God our own biases and bigotries," he says. God is, by definition, unhuman and is therefore impossible to conceive of—but we humans have a psychological itch that must be scratched: we're compelled to know what our god is really like so we fill in the blanks with what we know best: ourselves. One religion satisfies this urge to know better than the rest: in the birth of Jesus, God literally becomes a human being. "That, I think more than anything else, explains why Christianity is the most successful religion in the world," says Aslan. Reza Aslan's latest book is God: A Human History
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
REZA ASLAN :
Reza Aslan is an internationally renowned writer, commentator, professor, producer, and scholar of religions. His books, including his #1 New York Times Bestseller, Zealot: The Life and Times of Jesus of Nazareth, have been translated into dozens of languages around the world. He is also a recipient of the prestigious James Joyce Award. His newest book God: A Human History (2017) is out now.
Aslan’s first book, International Bestseller No god but God: The Origins, Evolution, and Future of Islam, has been translated into seventeen languages, and was named one of the 100 most important books of the last decade by Blackwell Publishers. He is also the author of Beyond Fundamentalism: Confronting Religious Extremism in a Globalized Age (originally titled How to Win a Cosmic War), as well as editor of two volumes: Tablet and Pen: Literary Landscapes from the Modern Middle East, and Muslims and Jews in America: Commonalties, Contentions, and Complexities.
In 2006, Aslan co-founded BoomGen Studios—the premiere entertainment brand for creative content from and about the Middle East—which has provided an array of targeted services ranging from strategic messaging to grassroots marketing to publicity and social media outreach, to producers, studios, and filmmakers—including Jon Stewart’s Rosewater, Netflix’s The Square, Disney’s Aladdin on Broadway and Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time, The Weinstein Company’s Miral, Discovery and TLC’s All American Muslim, and National Geographic’s Amreeka.
Aslan’s degrees include a Bachelor of Arts in Religious Studies from Santa Clara University (Major focus: New Testament; Minor: Greek), a Master of Theological Studies from Harvard University (Major focus: History of Religions), a PhD in the Sociology of Religions from the University of California, Santa Barbara, and a Master of Fine Arts from the University of Iowa, where he was named the Truman Capote Fellow in Fiction.
Aslan is a tenured Professor of Creative Writing at the University of California, Riverside and serves on the board of trustees for the Chicago Theological Seminary and The Yale Humanist Community, which supports atheists, agnostics, and humanists at home and abroad.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TRANSCRIPT :
Reza Aslan: There’s a cognitive psychologist by the name of Justin Barrett who did a series of really fascinating studies about the way in which people think about God. He asked a group of devoutly religious people—Muslims, Jews, Christians, Buddhists, Hindus—he basically gave them a form to fill out about the ways in which they think about the divine. And for the most part what he found was that they answered in theologically correct ways when talking about God as being, say, omniscient or omnipresent. But then he began to engage the same subjects in conversation.

[markmaloney]

What he meant to say is that man created god in his own image...

[MrMalorian]

I image god the same way I imagine Captain America: a character made to fit the needs of the time

[t-.-t.]

*Grabs popcorn* comment section is gonna be gooood 😁

[losttribe]

Reza has had his ass handed to himself by atheist debaters for so many years now that I can't take him seriously...there's something to have a 'big think' about.

[Enyonam]

The universe is created for us so well that it's constantly trying to kill us.

[jojosip]

All hail the flying sphagetti monster. The one true God.

[AtamMardes]

"Religion was invented when the first con man met the first fool."
Mark Twain

[stephannaro]

"How do we talk about something imaginary?"
"By talking about something real."

[Grimtheorist]

God, perfectly compassionate... still makes us die because Eve ate an apple.

[zanzivar]

Just be honest to yourself, say:
"""I DO NOT KNOW """, that's simple.

[finlaywells]

'Imagine' being the key word. All such notions of superatural intentional agency come from the human ability to imagine. We're making it all up- essentially because our self awareness makes us fear death, so we lean out for something that feels like security. Humans eh? Gotta love em.

[mtownsen]

The thumbnail for this video is clickbait. It's not about Buddhism. :)
There are a lot of good ideas in this video, especially the discussion of how the perception of the divine is consistently related in terms of our own humanity. Which then creates this contradiction of assigning mortal traits to the immortal.
This personalization occurs in other religions too, not just Christianity.
However, Christianity is successful for a myriad of different reasons and the one that is the most likely dominant is actually that the most powerful nation states of recent centuries have been dominated by Christian populations.
If the British Empire or the United States had a religion that had evolved from Europeans who had adopted and adapted Roman mythology, then this imagined faith would be a successful religion in the world today.

[JshReed]

"Just imagine the most perfect person; perfectly good, perfectly compassionate, perfectly sinless. That's God. That's a pretty easy thing to imagine." ~Reza Aslan

"Oh yeah, and he has superpowers!"

Boom! Now you're all Christian!

[trixie]

"Who is Santa Claus? One Ladies Auxillary answers the question better than others"

[MichaelRoberts]

It's like some of these people didn't watch the video. He wasn't defending /attacking or even condoning any religion. The whole thing was about people humanize their own god. He then brought up Christians as DESCRIBING God the best because their good actually became human. Therefore any description a human can think of would work unlike other no human gods where you would first have humanize the god. Your good could be the end all be all and this video would still be right. I don't know why people are just out to be angry or something.

[seansean]

"There's a divinity that shapes our ends, rough-hew them how we will."
" There are more things in heaven and erarth than are dreamt of in your philosophy." Hamlet/Shakespeare
"He who knows the Tao does not soeak of the Tao. He who speaks of the Tao does not know the Tao." Lao Tzu

[NXaiUL]

Interesting findings. The fact that he said this process of divinising themselves was cohesive all over the world says a lot.

[wanderinguser]

I thought this channel was "Big Think" not "Big Imagination".

[PJSM]

*"Who is God?"*

Your imagination, Reza. Your imagination.

[jamesguinan]

Reza Aslan, really? Hasn't this guy through all his lying been totally discredited yet?