PETG vs Hi-Speed PLA+ by JamgHe, The review and mechanical testing

Let's compare two different filaments from the same manufacturer: Hi Speed PLA+ vs PETG by JamgHe. Let's check the printability and the mechanical properties.
All test objects are printed on Creality K1 on 300 mm/s (for PLA+) and 200 mm/s for PETG. AMS Riser from PETG was printed on Qidi X-Max3 on 300 mm/s speed.

Official Website
5% Promotion code: RHAA4MNKTVDV

Amazon UK
5% Promotion code: QU5B-BGLPAD-2ACJB7
10% Christmas Special Deal: XBGW-E9J5TT-JXCSB9

Amazon DE
5% Promotion code: EEYM-8THLUQ-REMZB8
10% Christmas Special Deal : E3JQ-8P74GN-V8MLBE

Results in Excel table you can download from:

Patreon supporters have access to summary table, to compare these data to those I did in previous videos.

Contents:
0:00 Introduction, specs
2:14 PLA+ 3D printing
3:57 PETG 3D printing
5:54 Tensile test
6:15 Layer adhesion test
6:33 Shear test
6:47 Beding test
7:20 Torque (twist) test
7:41 Creep test
8:55 Impact test
9:33 Temperature test
10:10 Friction test
12:00 Results
14:25 Conclusions

#3dprinting #jamghe

[jamghedprinterresins]

👍👍Thanks for the professional tests, it was Suprise that regular petg runs well on K1, for K1 with hi-speed pla+, if you use default setting, try at 200 degree, the surface will be great.

[ivanrubish]

Really great review of the filaments! One is always a bit concerned before byuing a filament for the first time but after watching your videos basicly no questions left so thank you for the awesome effort and super research! Köszönöm Szépen!

[Andre_M_D]

Thanks for the video. I have tried quite a few different filaments and recently ordered a roll of jamghe HS pla to try out. We will see how it prints and how it compares to other brands like the sunlu meta pla etc

[NickBR]

Another great test video, thank you Igor.

[DJProPlusMax]

Cool! Will consider Jamg He next time I need filament.

[spongecounter]

Hi Igor,
Thanks again for all your work on the filaments, it is appreciated.
Another test which I would find useful, especially on the TPU, ASA, and PETG materials would be abrasion resistance.
Tom

[gothste]

Thank you for your tests, always very informative and helpful.

[DaveEtchells]

Good tests (as always) The Jamghe high speed PLA+ looks like it might be a good option, as it’s much more affordable on Amazon than the name brand PLA+ formulations. People on Amazon did complain about mild stringing though, which you also seemed to experience. I wonder, did you dry it before using? Some others on Amazon found the filament to be rather wet out of the box.

[avejst]

Another great revew of filament
Great job, love it 🙂

[MaciejStr-ki]

Hi, which setting You was using for PETG in creality print ?:)

[MisterkeTube]

Once VAT and import duties are applied the price doesn't seem that different from other filament I can get. For the Xmas holidays Sunlu had an offer of around €11/kg (+VAT) for PETG (at 6 spools), shipped from within the EU (so no annoying import costs - or risk thereof). Now, that was a nice deal.

[oldman]

Creality seem to have a problem with tuning their stepper drivers in Klipper to remove VFA (not ghosting)

[debrasam]

The Pla + hardened during temperature test. I wonder if its a good formula for annealing? Might be worth a test versus standard pla and HT- Pla.

[maggge]

I would like to see a test of creality pi filament dryer.

[Mbkelite]

Wow Earned a sub from me for sure, Great work!

[colinmsmall]

Do you find yourself preferring to use the Bambu or the QiDi more on a daily basis? Or do you have no preference?