How Hard Is Bedrock Redstone, Really?

Let’s see what the Bedrock redstone fuss is all about…

Music:

Chapters:
00:00 Intro
00:39 Java vs. Bedrock
01:30 First Look at Bedrock
04:59 5 Stages of Grief
09:32 Making It One Wide
12:28 Is This Bedrock-y?

[BosasoEiko]

When i first played minecraft, i thought that the "very useful guy at the very top left" was a kind of helper, that would help you when you got stuck

[mArmelade_]

Before I got java, I was a bedrock player and I used to do redstone there, it's impressive how quickly you put this together when compared to how long I took to re-learn it when I switched to java. Great video!

[BlindTiresiasInc]

As a bedrock Redstoner, you also have my respect. That's a dang fine door.

Bedrock has so many issues that I'd love to see fixed, but we've got some pretty cool stuff too. Have you heard of soft torch inversion through pistons? It's pretty wild stuff.

[MissPandarte]

I guess the only thing left is to make a 3x3 door that works both on java and bedrock

[AdventureMase]

as someone who used to be stuck with bedrock edition, its really funny to see solely java players try to figure it out for the first time 😭

[thrember]

like idk how you did but you did better than the most people that already did a tutorial. The hardest to deal with as a redstoner in bedrock like me is for real that its not consistent like you have seen recording this video. Great Job!

[Purple]

My only major problem with bedrock redstone is that it's so slow. And of course the randomness, but those are kinda related. The simple 2-4-0 extender doesn't work, it needs to be 3-6-0, which makes every thing bigger. Everything else is just different, not necessarily bad

[Piman]

I play bedrock frequently, and use redstone. I get why the redstone is the way it is. Its a lot more "friendly" as its rules are a lot more straight forward. Where as java uses a lot of unintended mechanics and quirks that arent really straight forward at first. I honestly think the wierdest part is that the two systems are so vastly different at all. That to me is such a weird choice but whatever.

[ready]

1:48 Most bedrock players aren't on a computer so they can't use f5. It is there instead :)

[syxalite]

~~The reason the door closes inconsistantly with the timings, is that delays in bedrock are random, there is randomness to the duration of ticks~~
Update order being inexistant causas the inconsistancy, thanks tristan for the correction

[tristanshaltz]

Soft inversion is my most requested feature for Java. Things like pushable tile entities would be tricky to implement, but for soft inversion, there is just a tag chillin' in the code that says: "Yo, if the piston is activated, pop off" that could be removed super easily, wish they did that.

[NakMusic]

I use the guy in the top left to check my armor without going into third person or inventory, pretty handy lol

and I'm just used to it from legacy console

[Fwog_scratch]

Didn’t relive you made this, I commented on one of your other videos that maybe you could try redstone on bedrock!

[BraydenDrummond-xomc]

That is the thinnest, most compact, bedrock door design I’ve seen! Good job!

[KU]

Meanwhile, me an MCPE player: "I am born in, raised and molded by Bedrock Edition."

[Kvngsoldier]

0:38 thank you, but as a player who had to figure out a lot of the redstone on my own, and got pretty far. I’d say, with piston doors, I’m not even making an attempt at 3x3. So this video was actually really helpful for me. 😅

[WintryBus]

Been waiting for this viedo for a long while, glad to see it finally out!

[bratworst]

This was very well done. And when it it comes to Redstone without pistonsbedrock does even better because torches and comparators can easily be one ticked

[blacklight]

Something as simple as a changing floors and light depending on the daylight cycle took me a while for 1 reason and 1 reason only, randomness making me have to either seprate every piston by 4 tick intervals making them stupidly slow or risk the chance that every time i turn it on it breaks itself.

[TheCoolTutor]

Anyone else notice that a sheep died at 3:06 that had been walking around for a solid 10 secs (sped up)