BATTLE OF THE 4TH GEN MAIN VOCALS - vocal analysis

hey this is a video that took alot of work and storage

Hope you like it and leave ur own opinions down below and who i had to analyze instead or in the future.

————————————————————————————-

All videos are used for entertainment purposes.

*All videos and pictures belong to there rightful owners*

Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use.

[jhayrownie]

the funny thing about this is that NMIXX sullyoon could also make it to this ranking. the vocal line of that group is just insane.

[darthestaaar]

haewon has a fullness/robust quality that is pretty rare in 4th gen, reminds me of older vocalists in kpop, its so nice

[marquersurlalune]

I agree. Ningning's villain is her lack of confidence. She can definitely opt for a bolder and more balanced belt but she chooses not to.

[yusraibrahim]

the vocals of nmixx is literally insane imagine having hard and tiring choreos and singing live too like they are really powerful sullyoons vocals are no joke too

[giabaomaidang]

I agree with NingNing analysis, I don't know but when she performs on the stages, we can clearly see her stage presence and her confidence in her dancing and attitude, but when it comes to live vocal, she looks like she afraid that she will crack her voice, her notes are mostly heady. I hope that she will be more confident in live vocal, she is a promising vocalist with a lot of potentials, I really like her agility.

[elmerbasig]

The fact that other NMIXX vocalists could also be in this list is insane. ❤

[TheBlindBandit-ev]

In ten years time, lily and Haewon are going to be absolute vocal monsters

[deyoncew]

1. Lily
2. Haewon
3. NingNing
4. Yunjin
5. Liz
6. Lia
7. Sieun

[martymarchh]

Now Lily A5 again in Young, Dumb, Stupid

The only 4th gen that can slay this

[rensunlife]

I really hope ningning becomes more confident singing live because this girls vocals are to die for. I think I kind of understand why winter gets most of the high notes now, I think when it comes to live stages winter is just more confident and goes for the high note whereas ningning tends to take the safer route and does it in head voice. I hope in the future ningning will show us a stage where not only is she confident in performing but singing too.

[dodorananda]

If youre lazy to watch the video heres the final ranking:
1 - Lily and Haewon
2 - NingNig
3 - Yunjin
4 - Liz
5 - Lia
6 - Sieun
hope that helps<3

[marquersurlalune]

Sieun is a really interesting case. She has SOOOO much potential. If only she trained in a more vocal-centric company or company with history of good vocal training like SM, she's gonna be unstoppable.

[preymeth]

10:22 is one of my fav moments of haewon's vocal omg i just loooove her vibrato here so much it literally gave me chills when i first heard it😻😻😻

[Jim-mwxw]

lia has my favourite tone in the entire 4th gen and is also my favourite idol along with lily. i really wish so much that a vocal coach could help her. her breath control and vocal support really needs help because why are you as a soprano straining bad even on a B4 (red cover). her tone is gorgeous, lower register has such a great quality, she has the potential but she just haven't truly unlocked it. she has nice falsettos and great transitions between registers too.

[moonlights]

NMIXX LILY ON ANOTHER LEVEL✋🏻
I saw her all performance (since 12 years old) she is incredible

[yerimissemm]

We all know Sieun is a flawed vocalist but I feel her vocal range in general makes her Stand out she has incredible accessibility in all of registers and surprisingly her lower register too

[sumi]

Finally someone else who believes HAEWON and LILY complete each other...oo i love nmixx

[quekquekkk]

All I know is that Lily has the best 4th gen vocals so far (for me). The control of that girl in her voice is insane. Even from a very young age, that was evident. You can even compare her to the best of the best from the older gens, and she'd have no problem reaching their level (e.g. the Ailee/Yuju collab). Give her a tad bit more time to develop and I'm confident she might just become the best kpop vocalist of all time

That being said, Haewon is definitely not too far behind. Nmixx in general has one of the best vocalists, so that doesn't surprise me. I agree with the ranking, except for Lily and Haewon (1st and close 2nd), and the last 2 in the list. I'd say Sieun is a tad bit better than Lia since Lia kinda struggles a bit even in the vocal range she's supposed to be most comfortable in :) Still... they're all amazing vocalists (and more importantly, they're all better than me lol)

[Rhaphidophile]

Ningning really just needs to work on exposure; SM's fault entirely. When she gets to perform live and she's in her element, she's absolutely on fire. SM forcing to lipsync their first three years was definitely a detriment.

edit: It frustartes me sometimes that she often chooses to be safe than risking notes, but I guess we also can appreciate her for taking care of her voice. Anyway her headvoice is immaculate and she definitely relies on it and mixes more heady whenever she's in doubt (which ig is okay considering how piercing Winter is).

[stevensong]

Lily and Haewon are the best 1, 2 punch in the 4th gen and then you add Sullyoon.... it is insane.
Plus every other member can support. ❤❤❤❤❤❤