The (Factually) Worst Survivor Winners Of All Time

Did you know there is such a thing as the perfect Survivor game? Well today we are looking at the opposite of that. These are the worst (mathematical) Survivor winners of all time.

00:00 - Introduction
00:27 - #1
03:24 - #2
05:55 - #3
07:19 - #4
10:50 - #5

[stadbab]

shoutout to natalie white for being one of the only people to win just by being a nice person.

[tmm]

Ben’s is the only win I feel really weird about because it just feels so shady. Whether it’s true or not, it feels like production wanted him to win so desperately. Ben finding all those idols and then there suddenly being a final four fire making challenge. Just very shady

[SpanishFly]

I get why he's not included here (since this is a math thing), but Mike's entire post-merge game in Worlds Apart was just so rough and messy. The guy would've been gone time and time again without Immunity, and if he doesn't have that Idol he's legitimately gone at Final 7 (he got the most votes, then).

[wunjo]

One thing that would be interesting is to explore what I call the 'imperfect game.' someone who receives no votes against them and no votes to win

[rohuisman]

Would love if you made a video on Myles's recent run on AU survivor. It was truly one to behold he had so many votes against him and was permanently on the bottom but always survived somehow.

[snobey]

5:50 Despite getting so many votes, I don't think she was at danger. Foa foa staying together + Shambo voting for Laura no matter what already creates at worst case scenerio rock draw - where Natalie would've been safe

Edit: in the bonus scene while John votes for the Natalie during the tie vote he says "don't panic, you are not going home tonight"

[AAG]

I loved Edge of Extension. It was so cool to see Chris come back!

[Nintendoshi]

One of the reasons Natalie was also voted for was because of the possibility of rocks and they actually liked Natalie the most lol.

[CauseAndCatastrophe]

I know Ben gets to face off against DevIN, but what about DevOUT?

[gmny]

The flaw in this video is that votes where an idol is played should not count. As the idol play like in Wendell’s case proves strength and skill, as well as the fact the votes “will not count” due to the idol meaning they should not be held against said winner!!!😊

[bravesfan]

I’ll admit. I’ve never thought about this, but if you had asked me how many votes winners received I would not have guess the 4th and 5th most would only be 8

[michaeldesimone]

Interesting video, but I think a percentage of eligible votes would have been more accurate. Chris was eligible for 43 votes against him and received 14, that's 32%. Natalie on the other hand was eligible for 111 and only received 10, so 9%. Makes a pretty big difference. For someone not on the list, Mike Holloway was eligible for 55 votes against and received 6 giving him almost 11%.

[crpman]

Ah we’re going by votes to determine messy gameplay. I think Boston Rob has the messiest gameplay of all time in All-Stars. The only reason the jury voted Amber was because they all hated Rob. Nobody respected a crooked player at that point. Yes I know this is messiest winners, but I’m just saying messiest gameplay of all time

[jonjanson]

These are some of my favorite contestants!

[darkonautgaming]

I was expecting Fabio and Bob on the list but I guess they weren’t super messy based on these statistics

[crpman]

2:51 Almost like they knew it would be a tie and are reading the final vote in the states…hmmm. Makes no sense to read all those votes for a winner on the island, then to not read the deciding vote until later

[btreese]

Why does getting votes in tribal make you a bad winner? It means people knew you were a threat and TRIED to vote you out but failed.

[TransparentEclipse]

This video format is flawed for a single reason: it doesn’t take into account immunity wins, and the theoretical votes a player would receive had it not been for those necklaces. For example, if Mike holloway played 5 (more) idols instead of winning 5 immunity challenges, he would literally have like 30 votes against him for that season, easily topping this list. So the method in which u became immune and therefore did or did not receive votes is flawed in this ranking

[lotpotflop]

ben's chaos is what makes him my fav tbh

[SchmergDergen]

Chris is the worst winner of all time, easily.