Barstool Pizza Review - Lenny's Pizza (Jamesport, NY)

The North Fork trip is coming to a close and Dave tries Lenny's Pizza.




Follow Barstool Sports here:

[tomoflathead]

"there's a smell" "there's a taste to it". lmfao yes Dave, it's food.

[kyles]

Dave is the greatest pizza reviewer of all time. even if he doesn't know what oregano tastes like.

[Face_Meat]

How has he eaten this many pizzas and yet is still unable to distinguish common flavors / smells like oregano or Parmesan?

[lazyblazer]

How the fuck after 100 years of pizza reviews does Dave not know the fucking smell and taste of oregano or basil. Jesus fucking Christ lol there's only ever a few ingredients in a pizza. Dave gets a 4.6 on this one.

[windog]

7.5 for me I can already tell. I like a tangy sauce and Oregano. It's probably Italian seasoning which I put on my pita pocket pizzas.

[Gladgrampa]

"There's a little bit of a taste to it."

This man is OBVIOUSLY a genius.

[krisfrederick]

Davey doesn't like pizza with taste. Everybody knows the rules 🍕

[MostRecentVersion]

I'd like to see a blind taste test where Dave tries two pizzas; one with oregano in the sauce, and one without. The twist? neither have oregano. See what he says.

[BlackAesop]

I had a friend named Lenny, He was equally the funniest guy I remember and the worst piece of shit I ever met. Everybody knows the rules. Pizza over friends.

[JonathanKim-eeiy]

calls himself a pizza man but doesn’t know “what that taste is”, everyone knows the rules

[burdman]

I feel like he just gave it a 6.9 so he could say “sex” 😂 that pie looks like it’s at least a 7.5. Feel like this dude is just trolling at this point

[mate]

My pizza consumption has increased drastically since I started watching Dave's reviews. I should stop probably

[VoiceorNoise]

Now that's a good looking pie, wow just on a visual I'd give it 7.6

[davidweiss]

The lady giving Dave the stare down as she went in was great..she even slowed to give a second glare.

[JSH]

Someone mail him a wedge of parmigiana and a bag a oregano so he can taste the difference. So tired of the BS “smell” and him not knowing what the hell he’s tasting!

[anthonyd]

7.4 - 7.5 is what I would give it based on crisp, cheese pull, and apparent flavor.

[blackburn]

am I the only one that saw that lady give him the stink eye for not holding the door open for her? bahahaha

[justink]

For a guy that eats that much pizza he has the taste buds of a toddler.

[Chronis]

I've driven past Lenny's a bunch of times and never went. Glad to know they're actually pretty good.

Though I gotta say that I was a bit disappointed that my old spot doesn't seem to have made cut on this pizza excursion, but after looking them up, it seems they were sold last year. Pour one out for Pagano's in Southold.

[cousinsfactory]

Dave should do a Long Island tour. Lots of great pizza throughout Nassau and Suffolk.