Barstool Pizza Review - Shelter Island Slice (Shelter Island, NY)

Dave is on his way to a North Fork pizza trip and stops at Shelter Island on his ferry ride over.




Follow Barstool Sports here:

[bloatedsodium]

One bottle of hair gel, everybody knows the rules.

[Av-vdwk]

Everybody knows Prez hasn’t been “mid-fairy” in years…went full-fairy at least 1, 000 slices ago…🍕 🧚‍♀️ 🛥

[TheMillennialGardener]

Roses are red,
Violets are blue,
I never miss,
A One Bite Pizza Review.

[RandyModdSteller]

One bite everybody knows Dave looks like he's Ready for a wet t-shirt contest

[mattestes]

Tons of these 7 scores lately I wanna see a slice that really hits hard -- naturally that's hard to find I realize but if it's not New Haven or New York it's probably mid 7's it seems like

[legionofbarry]

After Dave bit the crust, I was saying, "A little doughy." His next words were, "A little doughy."

[robertburke]

That last 20 reviews have been in the 7s... not a bad review in months. Dave has jumped the shark.

[namelyssactual]

I have guessed the last 5 rankings based on Dave’s vibes and my wife is starting to get weirded out by it 😂

[benvasilinda]

U can tell when Dave does a bump before the review, he talks about random stuff before taking his ‘one bite’. Everyone knows the rules!

[tonyc]

That Pizza would have been a 5.9 back when he gave real scores

[xJx]

Love all of the reviews, pizza is life.

[rafayseyal]

Love to see you do a series of all the amazing Greek style pizzas in Connecticut like East Ave in Norwalk. My understanding is this style is only in CT and Boston area.. not sure why it never made it out of that area, but it’s one of my favorites!

[thomasjacob]

One new can of Orange Crush, everyone knows Dave downed it right when the camera was shut off.

[krisfrederick]

Tom Hanks would have given it a 7.9 on his island. Everybody knows the rules 🍕

[normanwyatt]

Me and my buddies enjoyed drinking Orange Crush in the late 40's along with Moxie, 7-Up, Royal Crown, etc. etc. They were all just 5 CENTS and so refreshing on a hot

[vtrax]

You guys got permission to shoot on my patio today?

[DrPwndU]

Guessed 7.3 after the first bite, first time I've guessed Dave's score correctly... I know the rules

[chadlarkin]

Dave dresses like a gym teacher in the summer. Nobody knows the rules.

[PepeFrog]

Bro, if he doesn’t go to Oscugnizzos or Roasarios in Utica, NY then he’s never gonna score higher than a 9.3. He gave Red Rose in Springfield, MA (where I live now) a 8.2, which I thought was overrated but I’m sure they dedicated their day to making Dave the perfect pizza. Oscugnizzos has an upside down pie that just always hits the mark, and for some good old NY style pie, Rosario’s is where it’s at. A buddy of mines family owns Roasarios, which might make me biased, but I still say Oscugnizzos takes the pie.
My scores for these 3:
Red Rose (Springfield, Ma): 7.8
Rosario’s (Utica, NY) : 8.5
Oscugnizzos (Utica, NY) 9.7

[djmattn]

Loved Orange Crush along with Mission Soda after a great stick ball game back in the