The Yamnaya Culture: Proto-Indo-Europeans

Disclaimer:

This video is a breakdown of the Origins of Haplogroup J. I am in no way, validating or invalidating someone ancestry with this Haplogroup. All I’m doing is reading Academic papers on the background of Haplogroup J and related populations. Now when it comes to the questions of Shem, Semites or Israelites that is not the focus of this video. With that being said, I do understand that regardless of your Haplogroup anyone can praise and worship HaShem The Most High and join the Faith and take on the language, Culture and customs of the Ancient Hebrews of Israel. I recognize the fact of the Mixed Multitude and the various people groups that Ancient Israelites were around and ethnic groups who became a part of the Faith. So whatever conclusions that I have for this Haplogroup, I want to make that part clear. I’m not validating or invalidating anyone with this Y-Chromosome. All I’m doing is looking at the most logic outcome but I still understand regardless of your Y-DNA anyone can become a part of Israel.

[thehebrewofisrael]

Disclaimer:

This video is a breakdown of the Origins of Haplogroup J. I am in no way, validating or invalidating someone ancestry with this Haplogroup. All I’m doing is reading Academic papers on the background of Haplogroup J and related populations. Now when it comes to the questions of Shem, Semites or Israelites that is not the focus of this video. With that being said, I do understand that regardless of your Haplogroup anyone can praise and worship HaShem The Most High and join the Faith and take on the language, Culture and customs of the Ancient Hebrews of Israel. I recognize the fact of the Mixed Multitude and the various people groups that Ancient Israelites were around and ethnic groups who became a part of the Faith. So whatever conclusions that I have for this Haplogroup, I want to make that part clear. I’m not validating or invalidating anyone with this Y-Chromosome. All I’m doing is looking at the most logic outcome but I still understand regardless of your Y-DNA anyone can become a part of Israel.

[Ramiiam]

I wonder if powerful senior males claimed all the women in the Yamnaya homeland, forcing young and less elite men to migrate out in war bands to seek women and fortune? Before the Yamnaya arrived, waves of Anatolian farmers had already spread westward from Turkey to populate Europe. They had light complexion too.

[hebrewisraelism]

I have to keep making new posts because I can't reply to existing ones. I took a brief look at the first 30 seconds of the latest clip you referenced and I'm 100% certain that I'm on the right track and I can easily refute all this. I look forward to putting my study online. Shalom.

[hebrewisraelism]

Okay, well you have confirmed, for me at least, what your intentions are, which is to try associate haplogroup J with Yamnaya culture even though they are not the same people. This is to discredit J as being a Semitic haplogroup.

You trace paternal lineage when it suits your purposes, but other times like this the fact that these two groups have different paternal haplogroups doesn't seem to matter, because somehow J is being presented as the descendants of Yamnaya when they are not. The video you showed me says that the Yamnaya had about 15-20% of DNA from the ancestors of J. It does not say J are descended from the Yamnaya, big difference.

I could use the fact that African Americans have 15-20% of European DNA to argue that African Americans are essentially Europeans. Then I can say that Europeans are mostly R1b, therefore African Americans are Japhites because they have DNA from people who have R1b markers. 😃

Sorry, but this is not a science-based approach, you are only using science in order to push your own narratives.

[hebrewisraelism]

> I never stated that African Americans are the real descendants of the Israelites.

This is the exact problem I have. You guys are not specific and therefore the result is that people who have e1b1a are going around saying this, all because of your Natufian model.

This is from Second Exodus.

Highlights:
Who are direct bloodline descendants of Abraham?
Answer:
People with Natufian Gene And Haplogroup E1b1*.

As for my own theory, it's far more nuanced as I assert that there were many haplogroups involved and I explain why in my model. The fact that Jacob was J wouldn't exclude someone who had haplogroup E being present when the Covenant was made at Mt. Sinai. Shalom.

[iknowthetruthcommonsense]

most people do not study oral cultures, monotheism, is a haplogroup E and D custom, the abrahamic practices are haplogroup E, when the japethic nations, took the abrahamic teachings, theu synthesized it, with polythestic teachings, that where pagan, now there are people who arent biologically shem, but you can still be in the truth and close to the most high if you follow the truth, which is common sense

[ogahlatta]

Excellent jobs we have a lots of informations in common. Extra good

[hebrewisraelism]

I don't know if this is intentional or not but you seem to be subtly implying that the Yamnaya were haplogroup J and were found in the same regions as Turkey, when they are from the region north of that. "Haplogroup R1b, especially subclades of R1b-M269, is the most common Y-DNA haplogroup found among both the Yamnaya and modern-day Western Europeans."

They are clearly a different people to the Anatolians who had haplogroup J. That's why I find it odd that you put your disclaimer in about haplogroup J, which leads people to believe that these people were haplogroup J when they are not.

[indo.iranian.Jat.]

Yamnaya belongs to which Y haplogroups R or J ?

[hebrewisraelism]

> Lastly, I’m assuming your paternal marker is Haplogroup J?

I don't know mine because I have not done my DNA yet. However, I am Sephardic by my father's line and I have dark features and the hair at the back of my head grows in a spiral, like a corkscrew. So I could be E too or have some African genes. Either way, it wouldn't change my POV that Jacob was J. I just go by the facts as I see them.

[madmantheory]

These look like a common man on streets in North India. So one can easily draw conclusion that India is the source for Yamnaya and not vice versa

[ikartikthakur]

Are Sintasha from Corded ware or Yamnaya ?

[RealMadridBot]

What do you think the Vikings looked like in their prime? Ruddy?

[lemurianinvasiontheory]

Are Indo-Europeans descendents of Japhet or Ham?

[Chadpritai]

Modern Brahmins have yamnaya ancestory.

[exorientelux]

Yamnaya people were proto tukic people. They were Turks. We do not have to prove to European racists who is Turkish. You all learned civilization from the proto Turks. While you lived in the forests and trees, the Turks built cities

[hebrewisraelism]

I have an extensive report that is too long for video. It will be put online in document form. I may make a video that's an abridged version later. I have no reason to misrepresent someone's position, so if I get something wrong, by mistake, you're welcome to contact me and correct me, and if I feel I was wrong I'll update my paper.

That being said, I'll be straight up here and now. I have a lot of issues with the research you guys put out, so my article is critical in some respects because I believe your Natufian model is wrong and is also being misused by people such as Lion Farm to bash Jews. While you do put out disclaimers the bottom line is that people are free to interpret your info however they choose to.

None of this is personal for me against you or any of the YAAAP gang, I just don't agree with your methodology. Shalom.

[iknowthetruthcommonsense]

@hebrewisraelism, jacob aint no y dna J, that has been proven soo many times, to the point, where, idk why shemites, argue with non believers, at the end of the day y dna DE is biologically connected to the book, u either accept it, or find out when the most high judges you, the modern term for jew, is not cultural or biological, its more of a nationality thing now, big difference

[husseinealferjani]

Em123 is the only semitic subclade
Even other subclades of Em35 are not semites
Em2 is Bantu you can't change this fact

[Wolf-hhrv]

Please Shalom master some basic European language phonetics so you can pronounce place names approximately correctly. Delivery is painful