Have you heard the alternative version of Have A Cigar? #PinkFloyd #HaveACigar #WishYouWereHere

Have you heard the alternative version of Have A Cigar? #PinkFloyd #HaveACigar #WishYouWereHere #AltMusic

[dojyaan.]

I love this so much. It's closer to the live version.

[ronal]

the band is just fantastic - that is really what I think

[michelesoufferant]

J'adore cet album. Bravo et merci Pink Floyd de m'avoir fait rêver pendant plusieurs décennies. Vous êtes les meilleurs ❤

[BenKash]

It must have been funny knowing they wrote such a cool song that neither could sing well on. Good thing they got Roy!

[Krabi.explore]

I love more this version of the original

[manicbunny]

vocals pulled up give the song another vibe altogether - I am into that groove - thanks for sharing - the power of arrangement
blessings always

[SpiderDan]

Yes, very cool 😎 also Hats Off to Roy Harper for his great version too.

[alexteramo]

Wonderful masterpiece!
Alex from Italy.

[thisisnotachannel]

Yes indeed, I have heard (and thoroughly enjoyed) it.
It's very reminiscent of when the boys performed the song live.

[VincenzoMirabello-xyzw]

masterpiece song not vocalist Roger, and David this vocalist is Roy Harpet.Floyd this is band immortal history ☮🌈🎸🎸🎤

[_Frumious_Bandersnatch]

Roy Harper’s tone and delivery is spot on. Just a bit of snide superiority to the whole thing. He was a bit distanced from the “ideal” as an unscrupulous agent would be. Roger and David sang the words while Roy Harper almost spoke them in an exaggerated, phony way as if he was trying to convince the band- as the lyrics describe. The original was definitely the right choice

[timhubbard]

I have it! It's in the immersion box set!

[scotthutch]

50 years one way, honestly this is hard to listen to - fun, but hard … ya know? 😵‍💫

[badass]

Leave it alone. You won’t make it better.

[martyguy]

Sounds like a demo. There all over youtube

[MrConspark]

The band is just fantastic! That is really what I think, oh BTW which one's Pink?
LOVE PF forever

[shineOn_]

Roy Harper did a great job but I prefer Roger and David harmonizing together.

[franciscorenatopaulinomo-zpzc]

Weird David doing back in vocals to Roger.

[theshotgungamer]

Micah is not only a rat in the sense that he talked to the cop's. He spreaded his disease of selfishness and self centeredness to other members. (Javier, Bill, Dutch). He was the downfall of the gang. He loved breaking the law and rather then trying to go clean. He kept the gang in trouble and wouldn’t allow them to branch off into safer ventures.

[mikejacobson]

Roy Harper's vocal is much better.