6:00 Clock INTRO - Mangini vs Portnoy

The first clip was taken from "Liquid drum theater" DVD 2

Which one do you prefer and why?

[mtc]

We are watching one drummer in his youth, who is still establishing a name for himself and his band, playing the part he wrote. The other is a veteran, who has lots of accomplishments and accolades in his bag, playing the part someone else wrote. Before getting technical about drumming, very different phases of life and career already.

[MetalDrummer_]

I’ve always been so impressed with how respectful Mike Mangini has been with all of Mike Portnoy’s drum tracks and patterns. He replicated them note for note from the beginning. To me that shows ultimate respect and talent and I will always be a Mangini fan. Yes Portnoy will always be DT and it will be incredible to see him back, but not without feeling for Mangini and always respecting his time with the band. Kudos Mike Mangini 🥰🤗💝

[jameswise]

Portnoy has funky soul .
Mangini is more mechanical .
Both better than I will ever be .
Love you both .
Rock on my drumming brothers !

[amiseso]

Mangini for Dream Theater is kinda like Broderick with Megadeth. The one most technical player that really copy and paste every stroke very well with respect to the original players, but we know he is something else. Thanks for the years back, Mr. Mangini, really enjoy your approach and playing.

[trevormcmanis]

Remember, Mangini is playing Portnoy's vocabulary. Every drummer has their own. It would be interesting to see Mangini's "take" using his own vocabulary.

[jayg]

Mangini is still an exceptional drummer but portnoys cymbal work is unreal - his cymbal work really shines on a couple song and this is one. Also portnoy is playing at a bit higher tempo. I’ve actually seen 6:00 live with mangini twice and he did an fantastic job both times - just pointing out a couple differences

[GamingDrummer]

I've always preferred Portnoy's version on this particular song, but the ease with which Mangini plays it all without straying from the click even a little bit is nothing short of awe inspiring.

[Danumurti]

Wow, their 90's sounds so clear, so much clarity.

[drumcoverzone]

No drummer can beat Mike Portnoy's stage presence. The way he move, attitude and everything is makes us sit and watch only him. After all these are his own tunes.. no one can replace his touch!

[bastiroxx]

woooow, mike is awesome..
can‘t get enough of mike‘s drumming 😂

[sylvmili]

The first has the groove, the second has the bionic rythm

[duncanmacgregor]

These videos are fun to see side by side but every time there's no debate. Portnoy's feel and musicality is just lightyears better.

[DrumsDrummerDrummist]

So much respect for Mangini. Imagine coming into a band where the shoes you had to fill were Portnoy's. No one could match Portnoy's skill and raw passion. Mangini nailed the last 13 years in DT tho, as well as we could have hoped. We all know Portnoy needed some time out of the band and in retrospect I wouldn't have picked anyone but Mangini to fill the role. Thanks Mike and bring on the next chapter of DT. Eagerly awaiting the new album. LET'S GO!

[josebuzani]

Mangini is an phenomenal drummer and can replicate all the songs with no issue
Portnoy just has that feel and magic that cannot be replicated.
Both are great but I’ll stick with Portnoy

[jujuinho]

Mangini é técnico demais. O cara é uma máquina👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

Portnoy é essa maravilha que já conhecemos. Dois excelentes bateristas/músicos.

[ryujisan]

Mangini is like the drummer for Dream Theater at 5 o clock and had to teach percussion major students at 6 o clock

[TypeO]

The major difference is that Mike Portnoy played his own written song. Mangini played it just because he has to 😁
Both of musicians are multi-talented and well-respected.

[jamesnicholas]

Portnoy for me hands down! You can feel his energy and rhythm. Makes you want to be part of the show. Awesome musician.

[raicancro]

these two guys are amazing drummers, golden spot for themband work

[nightchills]

Both are amazing drummers with unique styles.