'Carnivore doctors” are misrepresenting the goitrogenic activity of sulforaphane | Jed Fahey

The carnivore community is in error. Despite the overwhelming evidence demonstrating the beneficial health effects of isothiocyanates, some anti-nutritional effects of isothiocyanates have been reported. One example is seen in goitrin, an isothiocyanate compound derived from cabbage, rapeseed, and kale, that inhibits thyroid hormone formation. But long-term studies in humans and rodents have shown that broccoli sprouts carry little risk of goitrogenic effects. In this clip, Dr. Jed Fahey disputes claims that sulforaphane causes goiters.

Watch the full Q&A here:

Original episode posted November 24th, 2020.
🥦 #Sulforaphane #nutrition #isothiocyanates 🥦

[ElizabethMillerTX]

I'm not saying that sulfurophane itself would wreck my thyroid. Especially not now. Not in 12 weeks. But backing off from all the phytonutrients has greatly(!!!) helped my connective tissue disease and autoimmune etc issues (EDS, Dysautonomia/POTS, Hashimoto's, MCAS, Gastroparesis, Sjogren's, siezures, blahblah). Stats, skin, hair, bw, bodyfat, BG, lipids, bikini-readiness, you name it, are golden. I have nearly always nearly normal body temperature for the first time in my life. I sleep! I eat and digest without drama! And so many other improvement in those really debilitating conditions. So, forgive us if some of us are reluctant to dive back in on magadoses of any of nature's plant chemicals. You don't blow the N of 1 off when you're the N.

[flipczech]

Thank you, Dr. Rhonda. Much love and respect for your research and dedication. XX

[davidjeffers]

I like Dr. Pratrick and Dr. Saladino and thats ok. Eliminating plants literally saved my life but I don't discount there benefits for many. Both of you are way to sure of yourself. Your attitude here is disappointing.

[jimantonino]

In general I find proponents of vegetarian/vegan lifestyles to be defensive to a bigoted degree. Not pointing to anyone here, rather an observation about intelligent people departing from the path of truth.

[mic]

In nature meat can be harvested year round
Not fruits or vegetables
So I’m with carnivore’s

[drw]

Paul isn't against plants. He's all for fruits. He's against the parts of plants that aren't made to be eaten. The fruit of plants is made to be eaten by the plant alot of times. The leaves and stalks of the plants do everything they can to protect themselves from being eaten.

[Sustainavore]

I respect both Dr. Saladino and Dr. Patrick, but the name calling and sneering is below both of you. Why don't you just have a friendly debate with him and go over the perspectives instead of making you all look like jerks. We just want the information hashed out from brains we trust.

[RoloSolis]

I think carnivores wants to stick it to vegans mostly. Most of them would probably not have any issues with what your saying.

[weichqw]

Love how he sites tooth and jaw structure as his reasons for use being omnivores, even though our biological structure/makeup suggests we were heavy carnivore who if need be could eat a little bit of other things but was built for eating meat

[nickdiana]

I’ve been subscribed to this channel for a long time. I forgot why I wasn’t seeing Dr Rhonda pop on my table, and I was unsubscribed. YouTube algorithm at work for big pharm, big ag

[gregpace]

I took sulforaphane tables for 3 months and didn't notice anything but when I ate the broccalli sprouts I could actually feel it working in my body and it felt cool. My intuition after taking the supplements was not to continue taking them.

[Idk-cimf]

I have a theory that your gut should be healed before eating broccoli sprouts or at least my case

[ilyAx]

I bought a sprouting kit over a year ago but never used it because I saw some comments on your Instagram talking about this. I’m happy you’re clearing it up, going to watch this video now and hopefully spring on the sprout journey. 🌱

[TM-cbte]

So if there is a volume of broccoli that does have a goitrogenic effect, does that mean that broccoli is less toxic for the gut than a food, any kind of food, that has no upper limit beyond which point it can be considered goitrogenic?

[rijokripto]

Why wouldn rhonda debate Saladino!? lol..

[XOX]

So many "experts" yet so many contradictory reports on the subject of carnivore and whether the plants are or are not trying to "kill us" I would like to see these so called experts have a debate ....it's so annoying to think you are on the right journey for health and then boom...no, actually you're doing it wrong....or are you....smh.

[CriticalThinker]

Here it enough and you start to believe it.

[loisthompson]

how many days do you grow the broccoli sprouts with day 1 as the soak day is it 3 or 4 days?

[montanak]

haven’t changed because of evolution it’s devolution we are all nutrient deficient that’s why our jaws have changed 😂

[dfusa]

Why test in china? Do it here in the US… and tell us