Homunculus vs Oyasumi Punpun | Better manga #edit #homunculus #oyasumi #nakoshi #manga #elderlybear

[dvl_kfk]

Teacher: Exam will be easy

Question paper:

[sohamchitkara]

both are god tier man can't decide

[ssgssaxel]

Why is bro comparing two masterpieces 💀

[homunculus]

As someone who has homunculus as the literal name, But loves punpun too this is fucking Tough. I think I'd still go with punpun but both are equally good

[ReverendInsanity]

I kinda have obsession with dark fantasy or horror manga literally peak at its finest

[somelonelyguy]

Protagonist-homunculus
Side character-punpun
Ending-homunculus
Intro-punpun
Impact(on me personally)-homunculus
Emotions-punpun
Conflict-punpun
Themes and philosopy-homunculus
Enjoyability-punpun
Overall-Critically it will be a tie between both
But homunculus is my personal favourite
So i go with homunculus

[mateogomez]

Both are Masterpieces, but take in count that homunculus was cancelled, by... certain scene....
If You know, you know

[thanatos]

Nakoshi and Punpun are kinda similar in different ways ngl

[louisv]

Great edit but I don’t think it’s a extreme diff pun pun kind of violates (heh mid diff at best) maybe it’s my opinion but homunculus seems to be a bit uneasy.

[Alejandro-frjc]

Just finished Oyasumi Punpun… I didn’t cry but I reckon I’ll feel empty for the next 2 weeks. Oh well. Time to binge Ouran Host Club and From me To You!!! Genuinely though, by far the most tragically entertaining and beautiful manga I’ve read, Oyasumi… Punpun…

[maruwan-dono]

i thought nakoshi was a piece of s but then punpun said hold my beer.. maybe o read vagabond prior to these two thats why. but hey in nakoshi there was still some light before the end..

[iamstupid]

id say homunculus....probably bcuz i read too many pun pun ripoffs or manga similar to pun pun before reading pun pun...

[marcelodubancaballero]

Yo al principio pensé que ambas eran del mismo autor jajajajaja

[Kakusseisha]

W opinion, this is my opinion

Introduction: Homunculus
Conclusion: Oyasumi(yes, The homunculus conclusion has inconsistencies)
Protagonist: Homunculus[(Nakoshi high-extreme diff (-)]
Deuteragonist: Oyasumi
Complexity: Homunculus
Depth: Oyasumi (could go either way)
Plot: Homunculus
Plot twist: Oyasumi (The turn that punpun made was extreme)
Story: Homunculus
Side characters: Oyasumi(Sachi, seki, Shimizu and yuuichi onodera)
Dialogues: Oyasumi
Main Dynamics: Oyasumi(Punpun x Aiko)
Pacing: Homunculus
Philosophy: Homunculus
Message:Both
Symbolism: Homunculus
Emotions: Oyasumi
Enjoyable: Oyasumi (Homunculus ☠️)
Quotes:Both
Realistic:Both
Psychology: Homunculus
Psychology Depth: Oyasumi (could go either way)
Character development: Oyasumi
Art style: Homunculus
Details: Homunculus
World building: Oyasumi
Self exploration: Homunculus
Consistency: Oyasumi
Panels: Homunculus
Overall dynamics: Oyasumi
Masterpiece:Both
Better than berserk:Both
Writing: Oyasumi
Overall: Oyasumi punpun extreme diff (-)

[MoonlightMan]

Both of these mangas are the greatest things I have ever read

[brounee]

I've read both. I didn't enjoy Punpun at all, but Homunculus is my second favorite manga

[darthrevan]

both are absolutely goated, but punpun wins for me

[xenozenith]

Punpun has a slight edge overall but homunculus had much more psychological tension

[ginamura]

Both are good, but you just can't beat Homunculus

[waldoz]

do not read homunculus and oyasumi punpun back to back you will get depressed :)