Shay Cormac Vs Edward Kenway (with detailed explanations)

hi lads. hope you enjoyed

acrogue acblackflag ac4 ac shay edward Cormac kenway

[dayumn_edits]

Ok so here are the explanations

Strength + Durability - Shay pushed back a charging elk which is humanly impossible. Durability goes to shay too. He got shot, fell off a cliff, hit his body on a rock hard surface. Was underwater for a very long time.

Speed + Endurance - Shay escaped two goddamn earthquakes. He many times hit himself while escaping it. But still brushed it off like nothing. His heart was being poisoned while running around new york. Lore wise at one point his heart stopped working. But still lived on.

Weapons + Gadgets - Pretty self explanatory. And if you're gonna argue that edward has 4 flintocks then shut up. Flintocks aren't even effective against a rifle.

IQ + Battle IQ - Shay made neglegible decisions which were bad. He's the 3rd smartest character in the franchise. For BIQ he fought in the 7 year war. So shay takes this.

Combat Speed - Shay was able to match haytham's combat speed and haytham can slow down time in combat. So shay takes this too.

Parkour + Climbing - Equal... The same game engine and very similar gameplay.

Experience + Battle Experience - Shay outlived Edward. No explanation needed and training his son and grandson.

Training + Tactics - Shay was trained both by the templars and assassins. Shay fought in the 7 year war which required brilliant biq and tactics. So shay takes this too.

Agility - Shay takes agility because he escaped two earthquakes while dodging Liam's bullets who was the most accurate shooter of that time.

Potential - Colonel Monro and hope both agreed that shay had a lots of potential. He could even surpass haytham.

Feats + Combat - Feats to shay. He wiped out the colonial brotherhood. Combat to Edward as he can hunt more variety of animals.

Stealth + Ruthless - Edward has a lot of tailing missions. Plus he was in the assassins headquarters for a long time without being detected.

Shay slams no - low diff
18:5

[yoinkreal]

Naval combat: Shay wins High-Extreme diff (Morrigan is better than the jackdaw and Shay defeated The storm fortress which is harder than Both El impoluto and HMS Prince combined) Shay also Beat Adewale. Edward is a better captain tho