DIFFERENT BRANDS - DIFFERENT SOUNDS! C TIN WHISTLE COMPARISON

**POCKET-SIZED PENNYWHISTLE POST**

Ever wondered how some of the most popular tin whistle brands compare sound-wise? Here's a quick clip showcasing 8 different C whistles, priced from $8 to $135!

For rewards, including mp3 files of my music, exclusive videos and more check out my Patreon page:

You can also buy me a coffee at:

Follow me on

CutiePie Official Merchandise here:

#shorts #tinwhistle #lowwhistle

[davidrumpler]

I like these kind of comparison videos… It helped me to pick out a Melodica recently, but I think it helps to play a longer section of the song on each of the whistles, especially when there are octave jumps involved

[moorejl]

I have been practicing on my new Killarney high D and find the tone is very clear and pure compared to the more breathy Clarke Sweetone. I do find more difficulty cleanly hitting the low D after playing upper octave notes, but I am a total beginner.

[mishfripps]

LOL 5 days ago I ordered a new C whistle. My $10 one just didn't cut it any more as it sounded too "tin-y" haha. Waiting on my Killarney Brass, 👍tx for the review Stephanie.

[michaelrs]

Being a killer whistle player helps. None of them sound a 10th that good in MY hands 😄
Actually I should probably put this emoji 😭

[jeffharne]

That was really cool! Thanks for sharing!

[Nangwaya]

Wow, what a different sound coming from the Clarke original, stunning!

[AntonNidhoggr]

Thx to your channel I've bought a whistle and practiced it for a week. Surprisingly it's easy to actually make something resembling music on it. I thought it would be worse :-D (however it's still hard for me to play high octave in tune but I'm working on it)

[Cysubtor_vb]

My first whistle was a Clarke Sweettone C. Nowadays my goto whistle is a Howard Low D and I pretty much play high whistle range stuff on alto recorder now, but I still ponder adding a low C whistle or even a bass Bb.

[arachtinilith]

Your video are like a little ray of sunshine, always a pleasure to watch and learn :)
Have you ever made a video of the Irish song : ​Johnny I Hardly Knew ye ? I would love to master this one !

[TheJofrica]

A bit hard to get the comparison as some of them were played in different registers. Thanks for sharing!

[Michajeru]

I'll take the Killarney thank you.

[rintintin]

can you do duke of death from medieval 2 total war?

[NoNo-hnnm]

can you do a tutorial for I like to move it move it please

[xenedraabourque]

The Brass & Nickel ones have a sound my soul likes, can you point me where you got these? I am having a problem with deciding if I like that brass one better or the nickel whistle.

[laurentgar]

hello stephanie the sound yo make is wonderful. but i have a question : is there a mistake ? Chris wall doesnt make any sweetbrass high C whistle but high D or do you have a special one
thanks again a lot

[ropegirl]

I'd love a recommendation for a "mellow" whistle that also plays well in the upper register. I have some Woodi whistles, and I love their round, mellow sound for some songs. But I find it's hard to get a clean sound in their upper register. Is there a whistle brand you can recommend that has a nice round, mellow voice, but also plays well in the upper register?

[Yuki-oics]

Wasn't the first a C# tin whistle ?

[dukesc]

Clark Meg for me. In sorely tempted by the wild Irish whistles though😋

[Lelldorin]

The Chris Wall Celtic sounds beautiful

[pills]

Why I feel the first two are the best?