Compilation of Stories That Genuinely Freaked me out the First Time I Read Them

This is something a lot of you guys have wanted for a while; these are 5 stories that have been read on the channel throughout the years, that genuinely creeped me out when I first read them.

If you enjoy this type of content and would like to see more of it & support the channel, feel free to subscribe and turn on notifications.

Anything with poorly structured sentences and grammar will not be read, so please just make them neat and understandable. Please also state how you would like your name to be credited in a video.

Music in this video courtesy of:

[athiefinthenight]

Gotta love the feeling when you're watching stories like this alone at night and then you start getting paranoid and start looking out your window and behind you.

[sevinlove]

I love it when he changes his profile pic around this time every year, really gets you in the spooky Halloween spirit for the season!

[kuromi]

The first story is so iconic. I feel like I've heard it 100 times lmfao

[angrysquirrel]

Got legit chills from this. Have you ever heard someone call your name but nobody is in the house? Happened to me once. Thought I was crazy. Never happened again. Husband has had it happen but it was MY voice he heard. I wasn't home.

[desktechies]

I guessed that first story, soon as the first sentence was uttered I remembered it like a core memory. It’s such an iconic horror story personally because it sounds like something straight out of a film, allegedly it’s real or at least real enough to get a response out of me in the middle of listening.

[tylerdrake]

Definitely need a part 2. Some of these are great throwback stories

[Raiinstorm]

The first story is a channel classic, I feel like everyone from this channel has heard it multiple times. After hearing the first sentence I *immediately* knew what story it was.

[librawitch]

That last story was pretty disturbing. First time I’ve heard that one. Shit was like from the grudge and that image made the story even more terrifying! Great video as always Mr. Nightmare!

[azedd_th]

Gotta be scary if it's creeped him out right 😭😭😭

[nicktheninz]

The reason why Mr. Nightmare is so popular is his no-nonsense delivery. I rarely subscribe to “true horror” channels because the majority of the narrators either have a voice I don’t like or speak with some sort of affected voice, trying to be scary or edgy or literate or urban or whatever.

But while Mr. Nightmare delivers each story in a very straightforward manner, he knows when to use inflection properly. In other words he doesn’t overdo it so that when he does do it it’s effective.

As a side note, I think he is also Chilling Scares. If not that channel is a hell of a copy cat. Either way it’s pretty good so if you like Mr. Nightmare you might wanna check Chilling Scares out.

[Madison.Dances]

Does anyone else remember that story where a guy went to the movies and he was the only one in the theater and then he saw someone poking their head up from a row of seats looking at him. And it kept getting closer and he decided to leave because he was freaked out and when he walked by the row it was someone holding up a severed human head. That story is the one that has stayed with me and freaked me out the most to this day 😅

[douteidesu]

the cabin story really creeped me out, the realization "the owner was MURDERED 2 years ago" bro imagine being in that situation

[JustPlanePyro]

These stories spook me more than the majority of big budget horror movies do.

[foxracing]

As a former pizza delivery driver, I can honestly say I have had a few really scary things/situations happen to me...which is why I not only believe story 1, it freaks me out. People don't realize how dangerous that job can actually be...

[ThetopGoat]

I love to see Mr Nightmare still thriving. I remember finding this guy back when VINE was the biggest thing. Time flies

[Meep]

I think I have an explanation for the one about the crawlspace. Someone was stalking his house and recorded his mom saying his name, explaining why it always sounded the same. They then used that recording to try to lure him into the crawlspace. Simple.

[therealMrA]

I swear the first story in this video is the one that made me remember this channel for years and periodically revisit it. The audio effects Mr. Nightmare put in only amplified everything. That was such a terrifying listen my first time too so naturally I feel warm knowing it affected him the same way lol

[kevinhuheey]

Sitting here, in a dark church parking lot. It’s raining, and I’m alone in my car. Utterly freaked out. Thank you Mr. Nightmare

[redrazorx-]

I just realized how close Mr. Nightmare is to 6 million subs and i couldn’t be more proud.

I’ve been here since Mr. Nightmare only had around 800, 000.

Edit: HE DID IT!!!!

[mx.menacing]

~TIMESTAMPS~
Story 1 - 0:09
Story 2 - 4:57
Story 3 - 8:33
Story 4 - 12:27
Story 5 - 15:04