Dual Clutch vs Manual Transmission (DCT vs MT) BMW M4 & M3

Dual clutch transmissions are taking over the world, they are great but are we missing out on the joy of the manual transmission?

Find me on Facebook here
Find me on Twitter here
Find me on Instagram here

[HenrySkr]

Sam: manual RWD car, temperature readings in Celsius, and 24hr time. A true man.

[TheChimples]

Most people say that a manual is more involving. Of course it is, there are 4 points of contact as opposed to 2 on the DCT. The 4 points of contact are: 1. Steering wheel 2. Gear shift (stick) 3. Clutch and 4. Gas / brake.

In other words all your limbs are literally engaged and therefore you are getting more feedback and your brain is more rewarded with sensation and involvement.

The DCT on the other hand cuts that involvement by 50% by eliminating the clutch and gear stick. Now the only points of contact are gas/brake and steering wheel. Maybe 2.5 if you count the steering wheel operated paddles as an additional point of contact. I don't.

But let's not kid ourselves, the DCT is faster and more efficient. So if track time matters to you (or gas mileage), the DCT is the way, but if you want to have fun and be more engaged, the manual is the way to go.

[jennifergonzalez]

I just bought my first BMW M3! I am so glad I found this channel. Nick, I've learned a good bit about my car just from watching your videos for the past few hours. I traded in my Honda Accord coupe 6 speed for the M3 DCT. It's only been a few days, still learning the car, but I am in love! :) I am thoroughly enjoying your videos. Gracias Mr. Kiwi :)

[HSSLTYO]

I shaved 2 seconds of my commute this morning with DCT

[willya]

Just ordered my 2016 M4 with manual and saw this video after. Thanks for comparison. Makes me happy I ordered the 6 speed. Cheers

[desimunda]

Nothing beats the feeling on shifting the gears yourself

[Shortyc]

"Oh, you could have gone 0.0003 seconds faster if you had the DCT option."

"I don't care, I'm having fun."

[MrDrmorbid]

Nearly 100% of the authoritative comments are from people with cars not even close to the ones in the video, let alone any of the cars they mention and fanboy in their text.

[JeanV]

That rev match thing is incredible on the manual !

[XtrAMassivE]

Damn manual sure sounds nicer when changing gears, it transitions much sweeter

[ferrarienzo]

I like how Nick veers off the road into the dirt/gravel 5:46 at speed in his M4 with no fucks given and the other guy makes sure to stay on the tarmac when turning around.. Typical Murray move

[TuddecBMW]

If I lived in the US I'd get the manual because I would be praised like a god to master the art of manually shifting gears (in the civilised world it's no big deal).

[itrsteez]

Had a DCT in my E92 for 3 years and it was absolutely fantastic, with that being said, there was just something missing to the total driving experience and I had no hesitation getting a 6MT in my '17 m3.

[gedam]

8:05 how far he is from the steering wheel is hilarious !

[felixarbable]

i feel like manuals might hold their value more being rarer, kinda like the gt2rs. nobody wanted them and now they are 400k

[GuardianofClevelandHeights]

You're a solid dude, Sam for letting Nick bring his dog in your new car! Good man!

[vinrave]

This put me in half. My first car was a manual, being a teenager I was very excited to have a manual, and now I have a automatic. As an adult it is more practical and saves a lot of energy especially when you're on a long drive with traffic.

My final thoughts are, the manual is more fun to drive but the DCT has better responsive time that gives you a stronger kick.

[jaysnsteelers]

DCT vs MT

Velcro vs Shoe laces
Machine vs Free weights
Treadmill vs Running
Non-iron Shirt vs Cotton Shirt

[FlyingAero]

If manual rev matches for you I dont see why youd get a DCT

[bomchickawahwahmatt]

Must be time to start modifying your m4 now Nick! He's done 2000 miles and he's ahead!