How to Overcome the Ambiguous Type Variable Error in Haskell's QuickCheck with Custom Generators

Learn how to create an `Arbitrary` instance in Haskell that only generates valid digit strings for QuickCheck, avoiding the 'Ambiguous Type Variable' error.
---

Visit these links for original content and any more details, such as alternate solutions, latest updates/developments on topic, comments, revision history etc. For example, the original title of the Question was: Creating a conditioned Arbitrary instance ( * Ambiguous type variable `a' arising from a use of `quickCheck')

If anything seems off to you, please feel free to write me at vlogize [AT] gmail [DOT] com.
---
Overcoming the Ambiguous Type Variable Error in Haskell's QuickCheck

If you've ever tried using QuickCheck in Haskell to test your functions, you may have faced issues with generating valid inputs. One common problem is encountering the message: "Ambiguous type variable arising from a use of quickCheck." This typically happens when your input requirements are too specific, leading the QuickCheck generator to give up on producing the necessary test cases. In this post, we'll explore how to effectively create a custom input generator that meets your criteria, ensuring that you can run your tests smoothly.

The Problem: An Introduction

Let's say you're working on a property test that verifies the conversion of a list of Strings representing digits to a list of Integers. To ensure the validity of your test input, you've implemented a function isDigitList, which checks if the list consists solely of digit strings.

You started with a property like this:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

However, since the condition is too specific, QuickCheck might discard a significant number of generated inputs, resulting in failure to run the tests as expected. You then attempted to create an Arbitrary instance to control input generation more finely, but you found yourself hitting errors related to ambiguous types.

A Solution: Custom Input Generators

To solve this problem, we can look into two main strategies for generating the required inputs for QuickCheck:

Filtering Out Invalid Inputs: QuickCheck generates a range of inputs from which you filter out the invalid ones. This often leads to issues, as it’s difficult to reliably get inputs that pass your conditions.

Generating Only Valid Inputs: Create a generator that directly produces valid inputs, thus avoiding discards entirely.

Why Generating Only Valid Inputs is Better

The second option is generally more efficient because the space of valid inputs (digit strings) is significantly smaller compared to all possible String inputs. Therefore, directly generating valid inputs saves time and avoids ambiguity in types.

How to Create a Custom Generator

Here's how you can define a new generator that reliably produces lists of valid digit strings:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

This genDigitStrings function generates lists of Integer, and converts each Integer to its String representation, ensuring that all generated strings are valid digit strings.

Implementing the Arbitrary Instance

After creating your generator, you can now implement the Arbitrary instance for your data type, which leverages the new generator:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

Validating Your Generator

To ensure your generator works as intended, you might want to run a test like the following:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

Running this property will help verify that genDigitStrings indeed produces a list of digit strings every time. If the test passes, you can be confident that your generator is functioning correctly.

Conclusion

Creating a custom input generator for QuickCheck can significantly reduce the frustrations associated with type ambiguities and invalid data generation. By ensuring that QuickCheck only receives valid inputs, you enable more robust property testing, making your development process smoother and more effective. With the outlined steps, you should be well-equipped to tackle the challenges posed by QuickCheck’s input generation and perform thorough testing on your Haskell functions.

Now that you're armed with this knowledge, go ahead and enhance your testing strategy with customized input generators in H