Why would Palestinians want a return to 1948? #israel #palestine #history

The chant "We don't want no two state, we want '48" rejects the two-state solution and harks back to a time before the state of Israel existed.But why?

#israel #war #palestinian #palestine #protest #protests #judea #empire #empires #twostatesolution #independence #sovereignty #slogan #chanting #shortsfeed #shortsviral #youtubeshorts #youtube #ytshorts

[badadviceforfree]

If they went back that far, there is no Islam

[paulperez]

And the Romans renamed it specifically to insult the Jews.

[mjordan]

And when the Romans conquered the kingdom of Judea in 63 BCE, islam didn't even exist. 63 BCE is 633 years before the birth of prophet Muhammed.
All the Muslims claiming "Palestine" is hilarious.

[Bertie]

Chanting is a lot more exciting than reading books

[CrimsonEclipse]

Pretty much Palestine never existed as an independent state.

[censoredandsickofit]

everyone is calling for genocide and they don't even know it, shameful

[ashishitD]

Kids this is why we should pay attention in history classes

[JoeRomano-sg]

There never was a Palestine and never will

[tamarathejudeochristianmedium]

Every time I hear a protester speak, it’s just emotion, denial, deflection, & buzzwords 💙🙏🏻💙

[lil_light_warrior]

The romans named it Syria Palestina as an insult to the Jewish people.

[davidrodgersNJ]

The Arabs launched 3 wars of agression against Israel and lost. Wars have consequences.

[holdupwaitaminute.]

They are protesting against their own existence, without knowing it.

That’s their level of stupidity.

[croybeck]

"When you don't do your proper historical research but still get mad when you history teacher not only fails you but also lectures you an the truth" 😂

[RandomBrit-py]

So basically, if you go back, the closest independent state was Jewish

edit: may or may have not started a massive war in the comments (what a shock)

[sarnieken]

They don't actually know what they're chanting, they've been told to say it. There are a few clips of this happening.

[Graig-kwsk]

There wasnt a palestinian state before 1988💀 so saying we want 48 means they want to be ruled by the british i guess😂💀

[NuclearNadal]

In '48, their forefathers took a gamble and lose everything for their descendants.

[ryn]

Moral of the story, these protesters don’t have a fucking clue.

[redactedagentdataexpunged]

'We want 48'

Your hear that Britain? They want you back

[TXDanielM]

Imagine the Brits or the French or Spaniards demanding parts of North America back. That's the logic of the Palestinians. Tell me which country on earth has never defined its borders through conflict?