Nvidia QUADRO vs GEFORCE for CAD Design-PREVIEW Benchmark

Benchmarking the performance difference between Nvidia Quadro and Geforce cards in Autodesk Alias. Quadro RTX 4000, Geforce RTX 2080 Max-Q and Quadro K3100M.

[MarkyDesigns]

Great video, thanks for sharing. Now I have a good visual reference of actual performance between quadro and GeForce cards for CAD purposes. 👍🏻👌🏻

[lorddarphyve]

I would love to see this in the same box with different GPUs.

[ProjectPhysX]

That is some heavy artificial slowdown in software. If it detects a GeForce GPU, it artificially throttles to run like crap. It's just garbage software.
The RTX 4000 literally is identical to an RTX 2070 with lower clocks.

[samanmilani]

That old k3100m keeps up really well considering how much faster the rtx2080 is.

[masfergi]

that's not how you do benchmark mate.
if you do benchmark, you keep all the hardware same except the VGA card.
not doing it in 3 different machine with different hardware. 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[amdenis]

I assume that you know that the mobile version of a given card is set to 50% or less the wattage power of the same desktop card? However, that is just one of many possible tweaks and outright design/implementation differences between a (for example), desktop RTX and the same basic mobile-spec'd version of a product line. I have a laptop with an untweaked mobile RTX 5000 and an RTX 2060 mobile that is specially tweaked, mounted and cooled on both the CPU and the GPU. I also have a non-tweaked (standard mobile) 2080 Max Q laptop, which I am soon selling/trading in. My tweaked 2060 laptop now runs at 150 watts of the 175 watts that the desktop RTX 2060 is running at, but it is a lot closer.  
So, the initial difference between my untweaked 2080 MQ laptop and the RTX 5000 Quadro desktop was huge on all rendering and display benchmarks, while my tweaked 2060 laptop is a lot closer (almost twice as fast as the normal mobile). My tweaked mobile 2060 is faster on several benchmarks than my untweaked mobile 2080 MQ. Not surprising when you consider how much they starve the normal NVidia mobile cards for power to keep from having to do a lot of expensive cooling and other engineering.
So, you need to consider that when trying to compare the regular RTX to the Quadro line, and not compare across mobile and desktop-- unless that is the goal of your comparison; but theen I would compare the same mobile and desktop card.

[mannyc]

Thanks, great testing. The Max Q RTX cards are downclocked quite a bit from the Desktop equivalent, especially the 2080 models.Less then half speed. The 2080 has 46 RTX Cores while your QUADRO has 36.

[salamatinatov]

It looks strange, when you are trying to compare between 3 different machines with different cards.

[ngm_]

Thanks for the video, however, this tells me nothing. you need to do the test with the same CPU, motherboard, power supply, harddrive etc with only swapping the RTX 4000 with a RTX 2070, 2080 or the new 3070, 3080, 3090, even other quadro's in the line up if possible. I know they are quite pricey though. Another far fetched idea is that you can try and contact Linus Tech Tips to see if they can do a colab with you. as of now, this is not a fair test. Though I appreciate the video. I just subscribed to you today love what you're doing. I look forward to seeing you carry out a proper test

[jperez]

That’s a pretty cool looking reverse trike.

[medved]

I'm trying to decide between a laptop with a GeForce graphics card or one with a Quadro. Example GeForce RTX2070/2080 vs Quadro RTX5000. I'm not into design so will primarily use this laptop for some work (I'm a medical doctor and the only graphics-demanding tasks may be to view occasionally xray, MRI, CT- contrast/3D scans which wont be often as i'm not a radiologist but occasionally). I will also use it for day-day web browsing, emailing, watching movies in high res maybe 4k and occasional gaming (I'm into strategy games like Anno 1800, Civ 6 etc.) Would a laptop with a Quadro RTX5000 be the right choice for me? Will it be able to handle those types of games or should I go for the GeForce card? As I understood it GeForce run at a higher clock speed making them better for gaming, does that mean they run much hotter than the Quadro cards? When watching movies and video playbacks in 4K is it smoother on a Quadro than a GeForce? Any help will be greatly appreciated.

[borgholable]

for cad a quadro will always be better, the problem for comes when i want to use a cad program like 3dsmax or revit for modeling, and then use another program like lumion for rendering that is for all intents and purposes a glorified sim game that benefits from using a gaming card like geforce

[AtotheK.]

How can you compare a Desktop GPU with these Mobile GPU´s - Doesn´t make sense..

[flaviodelao]

hello sir. I realize this is now an older video, but incase you still respond - I'm shopping for the best yet cheapest desktop for Solidworks. Am contemplating desktop XPS Geforce RTX 3060, and would like your opinion

[wei-paihuang]

Hi Kevin, I want to pick your brains again about Alias so sorry this isn't related to the video. Now, what's the practical difference between chord vs uniform when making a curve in Alias? In the documentations they explain the mathematical difference and some pros and cons of each, but I just use uniform all the time because it seems like your should pick one and stick to it. What's your take? Thanks for doing these videos it really helps to just hear a professional talk :D

[tayomwilson]

I like your glasses I've been meaning to get something like this, where did you buy them from?

[kuschpal]

Hey
Can you please tell me which cpu are u using with your rtx 4000??

[ryanrazer]

As someone already posted this tells practically nothing.
If anything, you can maybe asses both laptops between eachother. You can never compare laptop to desktop. Thermal envelope is on another level on desktop...
Plus, RAM memory, CPU also have an impact here. It's the CPU that instructs GPU to calculate geometry (it's called "drawcalls"). So there is waaay to many variables here to assess anything.

You should have one PC and swap 2 GPUs in the same exact set-up with only difference being the GPU that is being swapped.

[hamzahfanzuri]

Try it to render in lumion or different software render

[rmlambert]

So would you say this is due to drivers since a Quadro 4000 is RTX 2070, and I'd have hoped an rtx 2080 max Q at least matched a normal 2070 :/

I'm currently using an RTX 6000 but only use maya / fusion and rendering software i.e not driver specific work