AGATHA Ending Explained: What Was Missing from Agatha’s Backstory?

Before diving into the in-depth Easter Egg analyses of the final two episodes of Agatha All Along, Erik Voss is here to explain the final two episodes of Agatha. Who was Nicky’s father? Was a scene removed from Agatha and Rio’s backstory? Why is Agatha a ghost now? Thank you for your patience on our Easter Egg video — that will be coming to New Rockstars on Monday Nov 4!

Subscribe | Enable ALL push notifications 🔔

Follow New Rockstars​:

CHAPTERS
00:00 - Agatha Ending Explained
01:23 - Agatha Ep 8 Recap
04:39 - Agatha Ep 9 Recap
09:33 - Why is Agatha a Ghost?
11:03 - Who Was Nicky's Father?
12:45 - How did Agatha and Rio Meet?
14:19 - Agatha Missing Scene?
15:37 - Did Agatha Stick the Landing?

Written by: Erik Voss
Head of Content & Executive Producer: Erik Voss
General Manager: Zach Huddleston
Head of Production: John Costa
Director of Programming: Brandon Barrick
Senior Producer: Jessica Clemons
Producer: Gina Ippolito
Post Production Supervisor: Riley Auskelis
Staff Editor: Joshua Steven Hurd
Editors: Devin Cleary, Ed Vilderman
Camera Operator: Dashiell Hamingson

PATREON PRODUCERS:
Rick Denmon
RXJedi

[elisediels]

The song wasn't created to lure in witches. It was created by Nicholas bonding with Agatha. Eventually, Agatha realized it could be used as a trap for witches, but it was originally completely pure and innocent.

[byGodsgrace_iamchosen]

I just want to say that Agatha All Along is a series that respects the intelligence of viewers. Yes, we may need to re-watch many times to uncover everything but it sure got us thinking and that's a major win! Kudos to the cast, writers and Jac!

[HellooKitty]

In Nicholas’s bedroom was an award for singing. Ironically he started the song “the witches road”😢

[jeffk]

Just realized that “that boy isn’t yours “ line has so many meanings now… 1. Billy is not your son Nicky 2. Billy is not yours to keep 3. Billy is mine 4. Nicky is mine

[natenelson]

Hang on!!! The first episode where they have the whole "Agnes of Westview" the theme song says "Down down down the road, down the Winding Road", which I'm sure is the actual first iteration that Nicky sang!! Ending and closing the same, and it would make sense for Agatha to manifest that version instead of the "sacred" version

[volrogue]

I gotta say, I do love the finale being less of a cgi fight and more of a context epilogue

[wheeledjustice]

I just realized that the subway car being underneath the road makes sense now. Billy must have been creating as he went, only adding a section of subway after hearing Mrs. Davis offhandedly mention it early on.

[ericalee]

Small detail but I loved that the goat had the same pattern/coloring as the bunny.

[Radignostic]

the down aging on Kathryn Hahn was really subtle and well done. just enough to sell the time difference but not too much to look off

[KurayamiNeko]

2:34 i uh, think it stops being an 'accidental drowning' when there's a hand actively holding the kid's head down in the water 💀

[LeeCarlson]

Billy is not just a Wiccan but the Demiurge who can mold reality to his will. Agatha recognized Billy for who he was by the "tell" he shared with his mother—that of molding reality, so he created the road that the coven needed.

[LastKingLJ]

I thought it was said Billy was seeing a random boy die and that’s where Tommy’s spirit would be going into

[Doubleduperron]

One thing I noticed after (an undisclosed amount of) rewatching the last two episodes: Jennifer Kale is probably only the second ever witch to take their power back from Agatha (Wanda being the first) and will likely return in future projects, kind of neat if it were one where Agatha has possessed Billy.

[AbsurdOblivion]

I haven’t really been sold on the "next generation" narratives happening, but, I absolutely fell in love with Joe Locke’s Wiccan in this series and I am excited to see his world evolve. Nothing from phase 4 has captured what was great about the avengers until this…

[xx_sanch_xx]

isn't it kind of wild that Lilia knew the whole story and still chose to give Agatha life changing premonition?

[Hdub]

“This is my son, Nicholas From Scratch”

[KarinaTovar-bz]

I think the idea that Agatha made Nikki from scratch is meant to be opposite to Wanda’s and Strange’s conversation about creating kids from magic.

Billy and Tommy are magical and will not die. Nikki is not so he is dead.

It’s poetry. It rhymes.

[melbrown]

The 9th episode was clearly an epilogue, and the 8th was the finale.

[TheThird]

The boy Billy saw wasn't Tommy (yet). The entire sequence with Agatha was finding a vessel for Tommy to inhabit, and the boy in question was in the process of dying so Tommy could move in (hence why Billy asked if he was KILLING this boy so his brother could live, not that if he had killed this boy so his brother now lives).

[ACfromTheBay]

Can we talk about the fact that we're still debating whether or not a literal serial killer is just misunderstood or not.