Barstool Pizza Review - Sicily Coal Fired Pizza (Middletown, CT)

Dave thinks he sees the first 8 of the trip, but he may have arrived too late.




Follow Barstool Sports here:

[rufioswitch]

Owner waits years for Scott to come, they arrive 3 minutes late and turn a crispy 8.3 into a semi-floppy 7.8.
Owner’s dream ends.

[ImStuckInStockton]

Scott Portnoy talking about pizza that has been rained on for a minute: "I feel like this is usually crispier."

[etxkevin]

How is that not an 8?!?! That looks way better than 7 pizzas.

[Snake-filledChimp]

Dave lowballed those guys! Looks like a killer pie. I saw thumbnail and said 8.2.

[scottwatrous]

For a sub 8, Scotty was devouring that ahit.

[stevenzwolinski]

Ugh, hire a dog walker for 5:30 am, and bust out the 8.3✅

[prestond]

This here is Scott! From Swampdave. Huge Buckeye fan with a dog called Mr Britches. He loves reviewing peach pies. Heard he owns some sports bar, too. Real gentleman!

[sleepycump]

I'm surprised such a big Patriots fan as Pres didn't know Belicheck attended Wesleyan.

[nnnickkk]

Okay... That was a deflated score. That looked like a MINIMUM 8.1

[StuartElliott-qsbs]

Steve, Scott and Dave. The Portnoy pizza brothers.

[HughJorgan]

Dave grabbed a slice with a bubble for once!

[coldcrush]

Sicily pizza. Ciao, Scusi, arrivederci

[HUMCHEE]

BILL BELICHICK is a Wesleyn grad. LMFAO

[GRANTTRAUBable]

Nothing more precious than the bond of a man and his dog

[cisium]

Wesleyan _was_ my first choice. I wasn't Yale material so I didn't waste my ED on it. I just wanted the whole process over with, kinda like Dave just wanted this review over with. You gotta go to Jerry’s next.

[jnero]

That place got robbed.. at least a 8.4

[GickelsGaming]

Scott, what are you doing giving this a 7.8 that looked like one of the best pies so far! the char, the thin, the deep roma, cooked cheeses.
scott is the review king afterall, so everyone knows scotts rules

[amirraja]

Here we go, Scott is getting closer and closer to New Haven

[mclovin]

Thin, slightly burned on the bottom, slightly burned on the top, no flop, nice crunch, charred = high score.

[devingarrett]

Never forget Jack's Coal Fired Pizza!