Andy's Apple Farm

Just a perfectly ordinary trip to a definitely not scary Apple Farm!

[captaincameo]

"... You took the key to my house?"

I feel like that's the most realistic reaction I've ever seen in a game.

[minecrashinhard]

i love how Margret canonically waits for you to help, then if you put even one fruit in the wrong basket she just dumps all of them back out and waits for you to try again

[Chamble]

I like how Andy is the only one concerned about everything that’s going on. My man just wants his keys.

[notniran]

Mark: "I got your nose!"
Caluse: *angry cursed microwave noises*

[Ki-jdle]

Andy has the most normal reactions I’ve ever seen in a horror game.

[itzyagurlmadz]

Andy: “How long have you been in here?”
This man was more realistic than most people in horror movies

[dgtrll]

Mark: got your nose

Clause: *and I took that extremely personally*

[irenegarcia]

“Care for an apple?”
Andy, an apple himself: 😃…

[derekrequiem]

Mark had so much fun sorting the fruits into the baskets that he messed up on purpose just so he could do it again.

[ckuity]

I love how instead of just going with everything without questioning it first, Andy is genuinely confused and distraught by whats happening. Like, the man just wants his keys, leave him alone.

[josjos-xs]

Mark: "I've got your nose!"
Claus: *Demonic echoes*

[tapwater]

For those who don’t know, the text at 15:44 roughly translates to:
“But it wasn’t her fault.
We weren’t alone on that boat.
I don’t blame her.”

The thing mark dragged at the bottom of the water’s floor was the body of a kid. If you lift it straight up instead of dragging it you get a news report of a 10 year old boy who went missing after falling off a boat. His sister (who was also in the boat) returned home, but the boy did not. (Edit: wanted to also add a cool fact. If you walk against a certain spot of the trees you can walk through it and find the girl crying on the boat saying “I didn’t mean to. What will mom and dad say?”)

If you want more information about this games story then watch game theory’s video on it. The creator (who replied to someone on his comment) confirmed that matpat got it mostly right.

[fruitymctootie]

Felix: it’s the key to your house!

Andy: You took.. the key to my house?

Finally a mc who actually makes sense

[hjonkhjonk_]

Ok but the part where Andy goes “… you took the key to my house???” is really funny to me lmao

[claudespeed]

The scariest thing about this game is just how shitty Andy's "friends" are to him, straight up bullies lol.

[robertusestuslaflask]

The scariest part of this is when Andy is asked if he wants an apple and he just stays silent. He was so confused he had no response, or perhaps it was for a different reason. Either way he knew it wasn’t a joke.

[karzoon]

This game is basically the “uncomfortable but not really that creepy” game

[Rainbowfox_]

Felix: “hey do you want an apple?”

Andy: “what the fuck did you say to me you little s-“

[butterwithnobrim]

There's more. Depending on when and how you play the games, you can actually get different secrets each time. Andy's Apple Farm is one of those games that really require some looking to find secrets.

[lemonjuice.]

"You... stole the keys to my house?"
this guy isn't just a playful dude he's like 'dude wtf'