IS DOOM 3 BETTER THAN DOOM 3 BFG EDITION?!

Which version of Doom 3 is better, Doom 3 or Doom 3 BFG Edition? Let's find out!

Music used:
Dark Halls - Bobby Prince - DooM (1993) OST

HERE'S MY SOCIALS AND MERCH
-------------------------------------

CHECK OUT MY AWESOME PLAYLISTS
-------------------------------------

#doom #doometernal #idsoftware #doom3bfg #doom3 #shorts

[Vrillchill]

I think doom 3 is honestly better than doom 3.

[escapegulag]

OG for atmosphere, BFG for ..simply getting the game to run lol

[SentinelEx]

I just wish they kept the original Doom 3 main menu and the option to assign your fave weapons via D-pad.

[Dad.]

It surprises me that no one questions why the SSG wasn't in vanilla doom 3 or big edition

[blueorange]

Doom 3 is the best. I like og a bit better.

In BFG they disabled muzzle flash, some scripted events don't work properly, they changed Sgt. Kelly's skin, changed color armor from other marines but left the old color on desd pre set ones.
Videos in game were not updated to BFG visuals. But mods tend to fix this.

[Enkarashaddam]

doom 3 vanilla forever always. all files, all aspects of og doom 3 can be accessed and modded. it even comes with its own editor, you can create your own scripts with it too

[mrbigglezworth]

BFG edition has rather objectively worse lighting then the original that came out in 2004, and in many ways trivializes the difficulty by drowning you in ammo and health pick ups. When even Nightmare feels somewhat easy, that's not a good sign. The most it has going for it is additional content from the Lost Mission and having both Doom 3 and Resurrection of Evil packaged together, but otherwise I'd probably tell people to just play the OG instead.

[randybutternubs]

The deal breaker for me was when they removed the flashlight in BFG edition and replaced it with a shoulder mounted one. Having to choose between a flashlight or gun is what made Doom 3 unique and exceptionally spooky at times. I get that survival horror isn't everyone's cup of tea. But if people don't want to have to deal with that mechanic, either make it a setting in the options menu or tell them to go play one of the other doom games. No need to force the game to be dumbed down for everyone just because other people are scared of the dark.

[Spoinkus_thy_doinkus]

I like BFG edition more because it feels more like a classic doom game and it comes with all the dlc it also adds the original doom 1 and 2 into the game

[AnythingisBetterThanStarfield]

Doom 3 OG is better, but BFG Edition is more accessible on console which if thats the only option it isn't bad. But for PC the OG is better.

[rlcsvk]

for me the base as i loved the tension of not sure if to get vulenarable but see where i am moving or vise versa-bumping into everything possible but ready to mow down

[edmac]

Original with the shotgun modded to not just annoy enemies is the way to go.

[Amp]

its been years since I played doom 3 but i remember it making me nauseous and uninstalling it. Which is weird I play alot of FPS games and never have a problem.

[HlmntGu]

Doom 3 Xbox original edition is the best version, no further words needed

[slaydrews_garage]

Im currently playing Original Doom 3 on steam, I made it widescreen with a touch of better graphics. I love the horror aspect of having to switch between flashlight or gun.

[kizaruthegreat]

If you like horror and little bit of survival feel (less ammo pickups) and a flashlight or wezponswitch then OG doom 3 is the one. If you want a more action packed one meaning more ammo and a flashlight on your shoulder you should go for the bfg edition. It al depends if you want horror or a standard fps feel

[AndalusianPrince]

The original will forever be the greatest game I've ever played, ever. So much so, that i managed to make it run on all my phones.

[BMW-sdnn]

Hot Take but Doom 3 is my favorite Doom.

[PolymurExcel]

OG Doom 3 hands down. Especially with the HD mod, it blows the BFG edition away.

[ZSTE]

Still sad the Xbox version's co-op has been lost :(