Cat Valentine vs. Carly Shay 👯‍♀️ Who’s Sam's Bestie? | NickRewind

Today, we answer a very difficult question: Cat Valentine vs. Carly Shay... Who is really Sam Puckett's best friend? Carly and Sam may have been best friends since they were little as seen in iCarly, but Cat literally shared a bedroom with Sam in Sam & Cat! So, which one is actually closer to Sam in the end? Watch the video to find out and let us know your thoughts in the comments below! ⬇️

#iCarly #SamAndCat #Nickelodeon

GET MORE NICKREWIND:

The NickRewind channel is the OFFICIAL home of your favorite ‘00s sitcoms and NickToons. That’s right—we’re talking all of your slime-covered Nickelodeon childhood dreams come true! Get the full love drama from Relationship Timelines, see your fave characters like Sam Puckett’s Most Savage Moments, or find out what OG Nick stars like Devon Werkheiser or Daniella Monet are up to today with Nick Reacts and Throwback with Nick! Tune in every week for exclusive digital content from all of your throwback favorites like Victorious, iCarly, Sam & Cat, Drake & Josh, Zoey 101, and so much more!

[ari]

I love Cat but Sam's bestie is definitely Carly

[seanpierre]

I think Carly is sam’s real best friend because they hung out for a really long time

[IsaiahHarrigan]

We all know who is Sam’s best friend! 😊 (It have to be Carly because in my opinion Carly and Sam were best friends since they were 8 years old and they still best friends not to mention they best friends in real life too!) 😃

[ConnorMiller]

“I only have one best friend. A cool, fun, meat-loving, best friend.”
“Yeah, mama does love meat!”
Sam is Carly’s one and only best friend!

[jesseandries]

Carly knows a lot about Sam. They are without a doubt best friends. 💕

[nintendians]

both carly and cat are sam's bestie.

[karylleamor]

Carly is sam's best friend ever sense childhood, and in the future the actors are still best friends.

[ibojani]

Carly: Sam's bestfriend
Cat: Jade's bestfriend







Like if I am right

[Onyx]

Definitely Carly without a doubt! But I also did love the odd but sweet friendship with Cat as well!

[famillebikitik]

Did you guys know that in Jennette and Ariana are born the same day in real life?

[kawaiitwinsworld]

I think Carly is Sam’s best friend. They have been friends for years and Cat has been friends with Sam for not as long as Carly

[jrs.ogjr.]

I think Carly because Sam was nicer to her

[Guest-]

I think both. Both of their friendship is so Even tho Sam and cat got into some fights they still got back to friends!!

[azzz]

imagine Carly & Cat meeting though

[SuperNASCARrocks]

Carly is Sam’s bestie because they did everything together. They were inseparable from the very beginning.

[anthony]

Carly and Sam have known each other their whole lives Cat and Sam had really just met and was still getting to know each other as they lived together

[jourlenchery]

Carly is the most best friend that Sam has.

[robertruhiu]

Carly is the true bestie for Sam they’ve been friends since the beginning thus creating the very own popular web-show ICarly.

[reutbudany]

Everyone knows carly but cat also a cute bestie

[isaacogunmuko]

Sam and Cat: Cat was Carly's replacement
New iCarly: Harper is Sam's replacement