Emma: 'You Left Me?!' (Once Upon A Time S2E14)

The scene from OUAT S2E14: Manhattan that disclosed what was actually inside the box that August showed to Neal from S2E6: Tallahassee

Well, I was expecting something more magical or maybe a piece of Rumple's possession but I guess that was good enough. Hee.

Worthy quote:
1:04 Emma: You left me?! And let me go to prison because PINOCCHIO ask u too?!
Well, if I were in that bar listening to their conversation, I might gave Neal an awkward stare. :D

Do share with all the ONCERS out there!
Feel free to request any past OUAT scenes. I'll try to give it to ya dearie.
#oncers #OUATmoments #S2E14

[muncraft]

"You left me and let me go to prison because Pinocchio told you to?" Morrison's delivery of this line was really good 👏🏻

[classics]

Baelfire and Neal being the same person was one of the most satisfying reveals in TV history.

[Smack]

"Maybe something good came from us being together." And I think of a certain browned haired boy by the name of Henry.

[ericajane]

Emma: You believe in that???
Neal: considering that I have been to neverland, met captain hook, am about 300 years old, have a dad who is immortal and can't be killed and has awesome magical powers, fell through a magical portal that led me to another world.... yes, yes i do.

[drlee]

I am just so blown away by how GOOD Morrison's acting is in this scene! Not trying to knock her on the rest of the show, but she is just so natural here. Maybe because the dialogue feels so organic, so real and she is channeling the damaged, pre-Storybrooke version of Emma Swan that lived life as an orphan and betrayed by the man she has to face once again in Neal. When I re-watch this scene versus so many others, it doesn't even feel like the same show at times. The writing, acting, the everything in this episode was just so Emmy-worthy!

[sdm]

Imagine you’re a bar patron and you overhear any part of the conversation

“Sweet Jesus how much did I have?”

[UserName-xirm]

I will never forgive the writers killing off baelfire 😭💔

[xCanYouFeelTheLovex]

I do see Neal's side of things. He was trying to fix his father's mess, since Rumple helped Regina set the curse. He wanted Emma to reunite with her family. Yes, it hurt her, but in the end, he did the right thing. Not that I don't see Emma's side as well, I definitely do.

[Shiirow]

"Maybe something good came from us being together."
"Nope, nothing that I can think of.."

Damn Henry, your mom just demoted you to 'nothing good'.

[scorpiodrake]

Michael Raymond-James was so good in this episode. Loved the way he looks at Emma throughout. He still loves her.

[angelwithashotgun]

Jennifer Morrison deserves all the awards. I watch this scene over and over again, and it breaks my heart every time again how she says "how?" trying not to cry, trying to keep her walls up in front of the guy who left her. JMo is a damn good actress... and this scene is still as heart-breaking as it was 3 months ago.

[DarthRushy]

Maybe it was fate. "You believe in that?!"

says the woman who's parents are Prince Charming and Snow White.

[madisonpointermusic]

Out of context, they sound so insane! "because Pinocchio told you to?"

[rafsolo]

The line about Pinocchio still cracks me up. I never thought about it like that until she said it. It's so funny! LOL!

[kayleighwilson]

I'm a Captain Swan shipper, and I never really took to Neal in the short time that we had with him, but I honestly was so upset when they killed him off. I feel like he should have stayed alive for Henry because I really liked their dad/son relationship. I didn't really have enough time to REALLY like Neal because I feel like we didn't get much time with him. I'm not going to bash Neal-I'm not going to bash anybody-but I feel like it would have been cool to see Emma and Neal develop a friendship and raise their son together. Keep in mind: before Neal and before Killian, there was just Emma. There was a character named Emma Swan who was badass without a man and who wasn't in a love triangle that had Swanfire shippers or Captain Swan shippers getting into internet fights over which side was better. There was Emma and Henry and a single message that the show provided-hope, not romance. I'm for Captain Swan, but I'm for Emma Swan's happiness even more.

[NovelNanny]

This is right after Emma got off the phone with her mother, It is so sweet the way she is gripping the phone as if clinging to her mothers advice.

[MartialArtsCat]

When emma said that nothing good came out of their relationship I was like, "uh, Henry for starters?"

[petraoconnor]

It’s kinda scary to think about everyone Emma really had a close connection with before she went to storybrook was from the enchanted Forrest. Lily maleficent daughter, Neil is Baelfire, august is Pinocchio, Sarah is Ingrid, Merlin showed up in the theater that one time like no matter what even if Henry was never born Emma couldn’t stop her destiny

[my-edits]

Lads I'm looking at this 10 years later and then I see comments form like 9 six years ago wow


I still love this scene

[DetectiveJulie]

Personally I would blame Pinocchio/August more than Baelfire/Neal.