Can Josh Recreate A Dish From Taste Alone?

Today, Josh is tasting one of Reddit's most horrifying dishes and seeing if he can recreate it without a recipe!

Check out our podcast, A Hot Dog Is A Sandwich!

Click the bell icon so you'll know when we add a new video!

Want more Mythical Kitchen? Check out these playlists:

Follow Mythical Kitchen:

Follow Mythical:

Check Out Our Other Mythical Channels:

Closed Captioning provided by Rev

Get Mythical Kitchen gadgets and equipment!

[TDCloud-cumt]

i cant decide if telling him beforehand how many ingredients went into a dish would make this better or worse... on one hand, we get the sheer delight of seeing him put 9 types of pasta into a pot of boiling water, but on the other hand we'd get to see his mind break as he desperately tries to hold himself back from adding 9 types of pasta to a pot of boiling water because only 5 things went into the dish he tasted. either way, i'd love to see this as a series XD

[lowselfesteve]

Josh squirting lemon juice into a jello, avocado, greek yogurt abomination from 10 feet away and then stirring with the back of a knife was so chaotic and disturbing and just incredibly on brand. More of this series please

[meadow]

I am actually astonished that Josh made what appears to be a better tasting dish despite having a, in my opinion, more horrifying mix of ingredients

[wild-eyemiller]

Definitely getting the sense that Josh is going to make the food crime even more heinous. I'm so ready.

[SlyTurtle]

Josh going through the process of finding CORN was amazing. Amazing concept and episode guys. Pure chaos and brilliance.

[bearpawdgamr]

Josh sucking avocado yogurt jello off the back end of a sharp knife while boiling 5 types of noodles and bread was not what I was expecting, and yet it’s exactly what I expected

[Kelly-ibhf]

We need Try Guys Without A Recipe style editing here, jumping between footage of Lily making the original dish and then Josh doing everything wrong

[Kobra]

This would be really cool to see how all the chefs compete to see who gets the closest. Could easily turn into a series.

[Beanielynn]

This feels like the off brand version of BA’s Chris Morocco’s reverse engineering and I love it. Make this a series

[sarahkay]

i don’t know why i had so much faith in him in the beginning but i’m honestly not mad that josh completely failed. the complete antithesis to chris morocco but it’s beautiful

[CyberKirby]

More horrifying dishes like this please. I nominate the Party Cheese Salad.

[atx]

Lily- "this is so good!"
Josh with hope in his eyes and love in his heart - "REALLY?"
Lily - no....
I saw Josh's heart shrink a little. 😆

[Zuub]

You know... I was thinking how could Josh mix that up for refried beans, and then he called it bean puree... and you know, hummus is literally bean puree.

[ambozz]

"There was a cheese"
"There is feta cheese in the fridge"
"I don't know where the sourness came from"

[rdprulez]

This video had me genuinely curious if Josh could pull off a completed dish based on clues left behind like in Crime Scene Kitchen. They could even make it a competition. Josh and Lily vs Nicole and Trevor, and Vi can be the judge.

[Mountain-Man-]

Lily is the perfect counterbalance to Josh's chaotic energy. This concept works tremendously well!

[abeehhh]

josh just casually dumping the pasta into the boiling water using his hands is top tier

[mpbx]

Props to Josh getting three ingredients right out of 907 in the middle of a fugue state!

[firstnamelastname]

I love lily's "This is so good" and Josh's reaction to it. And Josh's ramen cup opening strategy is top tier.

[greythumbshenanigans]

This just seals the deal that the Sorted boys and Josh need to get together for a panic filled pass it on - where he'll strangely ( maybe ) be the calm one depending on if he goes before or after Barry.