How to Properly Handle Data Validation in Service Layer for .NET Core API

Learn effective strategies for returning status codes and error messages from the service layer to the controller in a .NET Core API.
---

Visit these links for original content and any more details, such as alternate solutions, latest updates/developments on topic, comments, revision history etc. For example, the original title of the Question was: What should the service layer return to the controller when validating data in service layer for a .NET Core API?

If anything seems off to you, please feel free to write me at vlogize [AT] gmail [DOT] com.
---
How to Properly Handle Data Validation in Service Layer for .NET Core API

In the realm of .NET Core API development, managing data validation is crucial for ensuring that your application runs smoothly and provides informative feedback to users. A common challenge faced by developers is understanding how to effectively return status codes and error messages from the service layer back to the controller. If you are optimizing your API architecture and moving validation logic from the controller to the service layer, this guide will guide you through the best practices in achieving this.

The Problem: Data Validation in the Service Layer

As in many applications, you may be working with a car API structured with three main components: the controller, service, and repository. The responsibility of the data validation is crucial on the server-side as it ensures that any data being processed meets the necessary criteria. An effective strategy is required to handle these validations in the service layer while allowing the controller to relay relevant responses back to the client.

For example, in the controller method GetById, different scenarios are currently handled directly within the method. However, there's a need to refactor this logic to allow for cleaner, more maintainable code by relocating it to the service layer.

Example of Current Controller Logic

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

The Solution: Effective Data Handling in Service Layer

1. Avoid Returning IActionResult from Service Layer

The first best practice to adopt is to avoid returning IActionResult directly from your service methods. This tight coupling can lead to issues later on. Instead, consider several strategies for returning validation results back to the controller.

2. Utilizing Exceptions (Sparingly)

Use Case: For unexpected failures or exceptional circumstances.

How: Only catch exceptions thrown by the repository in your controller and return an appropriate 5xx response.

3. Implementing a Result Wrapper

What it is: Create a CarResult class that encapsulates your Car object, a list of errors, and a success status.

Advantages: This method is beneficial for capturing multiple validation errors in one go.

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

Controller Implementation: Handle the overall results in the controller.

4. Using Out Parameters

Definition: Change your service method signature to include out parameters.

Example:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

5. Discriminated Unions (Advanced)

Purpose: This option provides a comprehensive way to report multiple outcomes by defining a result type that can express success, validation failure, or exceptions.

Consideration: While powerful, it can introduce extra complexity in handling responses.

6. Mapping Results to IActionResult in Controller

Regardless of the method chosen, always ensure that you map success or error results back to an IActionResult appropriately in your controller.

Conclusion

By strategically handling data validation within your service layer, you can clean up your code, enhance maintainability, and provide clearer feedback to users. Choose a method that fits your application's complexity and team’s preference, and always aim for a solution that keeps your service layer decoupled from your presentation layer.

Implementing these practices will improve the robustness and clarity of your API, ultimately leading to a better user experience.