Red Card or No? The Most Controversial Red Cards

Instant Replay looks back at the most controversial red card and yellow cards of the MLS is Back Tournament. Do you agree with the color of the card the referee issued?

[corytoews]

3:26: "Charlie, you're not yelling enough" "Oh, ok"

[TacticalManager]

Yes, these plays can cause serious injuries and the excessive force is not needed. Tactical Manager wants players healthy so he can make more videos😂🤙🏽⚽️

[alexisbuffon]

4:00 worst call ever made in the history! Are you blind?? That was the most obvious fake ever! Waston clearly dived way after the little contact that happened just after he pushed the Atalanta player in the box. That was more a penalty from Watson than a red card for a player who just attempts to get up and skims a professionnal actor.

[hmogoblin]

The way the ref holds the card at 4:24 😂😂

[madman]

Get charlie outta here. Bring simon back, not everything is a red card

[YTLovekangkai]

Thanks for the instant reply! As a US certified referee, I could learn a lot from this videos.

[bryanmartinez]

The first one wasn't even a red. The attacker di not have a clear goal and they were both struggling for a free ball that was in posession of noone. The rest of them are just the MLS being all sensitive, you guys call every foul for a red card, let the players loose a bit; besides all of them yell like hell after a simple foul, looking for a card.

[oliveranderson]

What about Valeri getting kicked in the face during the final??

[Aldertur]

everything is not executive force. if you gave reds as often as you feel the should be. they would have to carry over and called in another game and then we would be lucky to have a 7v7 game.

[DukeTrout]

3:15 I hate it when refs hand out cards when a player runs through or into an obvious kick. Jonathan Mensa was winding up to kick that ball, and the attacker just runs right through his leg. I’d actually go yellow the other way on that one. 4:00 Red for the kick out, for sure, but why no card for Waston stepping on a player? He’d have been carded for sure if not for the retaliation. 5:20 What? Elis’ hand didn’t deflect off of anything, and he’s looking right at Tuiloma when he does it. Give me a break. He got off easy on the first yellow when he stomps on/throws a shoulder into Villefana’s face.

[dirislecabdi]

John champion please come back premier league where are you going USA league poor league

[ballpool]

Why is American football camera & the field looks like fifa while European league more like pes