Which Version Of This Song Is The Best? Jason Derulo “Whatcha Say” & Imogen Heap #shorts #sample

[miauelgato]

"the shooting aka dear sister"

[christiandiaz]

Reading the comments and I start realizing people have nostalgia for the Jason Derulo version and not the Imogen Heap original.
I’m getting old.

[lilacsstay]

HIDE AND SEEK IS SUCH A GOOD SONG LISTEN TO THE LYRICS

[sqralenz]

that sounds more like kids bop than jason derulo

[candirobinson]

Just listened to the original omosh it's so beautiful if you listen to the whole song.

[marcuseditzTM]

Their both iconic, but I'll have to go with hide and seek because of the memes

[ArteriotomyMusic]

both are really good but the imogen heap original is still one of the most beautiful songs ever made 18 years later, and with just one (two if u count the carrier and vocal tracks inside the vocoder separately) instrument in it and that has to be worth something

[sushiluver]

Love these songs


Plus love the fact they always used og in those 2000 to 2010 shows

[kelvinMidulOfficial]

Goddamn you gave me a vine flashback back in 2013 to 2016 good ol days isn't it😭

[paigeproctor]

Both. Love this song. I remember listening to it on the oc. Now there's an older show

[tomatostarz]

heap sweeped it ngl that one is just perfect meme material and so, , , , ETHEREAL dude

[-Jozef]

If anyone thinks the original isn’t better, I question your mental health😂

[jessywest]

Imogen, though. And Ariana Grande's loop cover of one of Imogen Heap's songs, is forever a winner 🏆

[owtsideperspective]

I loved the Derulo version didn't know about the other

[jeromeburwell]

Hide and Seek every single time! Imogen Heap is a BEAST!!

[mugiwara_for_lyf]

My All time fav song i hv ever listened idk it has that calming feel to it. No song can replace it❤️

[anyany]

Well, the issue here is you cannot really compare them because both songs are structured so differently.

Jason Derulo's song has that verse as the hook all throughout the song, his song is built around that verse.

Jason's song structure:

Hook (Whatcha say)
Verse 1
Hook (Whatcha say)
Verse 2
Hook (Whatcha say)
Breakdown
Verse 2.5
Hook/Outro (Whatcha say)

The original song however is about other things and that "hook" is just a small part of the song as a whole.

Imogen Heap structure:

Verse 1
"Hook" (Pseudo)
"Breakdown"
"Hook" (Pseudo)
True Hook (Whatcha say)
2 verse Pseudo Outro
True Outro

It's apples to oranges.

[SuburbanIrvin]

Jason is more nostalgic but you can’t replace the original

[jashardwallington]

Imogen heap needs more credit so many samples from her music

[shaybarcellyia]

Jason Derulo. Soo many high school memories