What if Austria Collapsed in 1910? (Viewer Votes!)

#possiblehistory #ph
Link to the next viewer vote:

If you like the content please like, comment and subscribe, it helps channels like mine to get noticed!

If you want to support the channel you can go to my Patreon or become a member! You will get early access to video's and will be allowed to suggest priority video subjects!

Feel free to follow or join our social media platforms:

[GigaRoman]

What if everything went perfect for Italy?

[Maltheus_]

Why would Germany lose territory after the war against the Entente when they've occupied large parts of western Russia and northern France? A return to status quo would be way more likely, but I could maybe see the French getting Alsace-Lorraine to lower the tensions with the Germans, but Russia gaining Posen? No way in hell. In what position would the Russians be to annex Posen when the Germans have pushed them to Kiev?

[Janvoj]

7:27 "makes some minor victories" procceds to take half of poland

[Das-ist-k-ein-VIRUS]

I think the most interesting is the moderate entente victory and the German British cooperation

[Melnek]

Your predictions for the advanced war in the "Germany rejects British mediation" scenario in the "late war" option do not match the reality of the scenario, yes, Germany is devoid of its Habsburg ally, but this alliance was more relevant at the beginning of the war where had to deal with both Russia and enemies in the Balkans at the same time, historically, after the Russian revolution, the Habsburg usefulness and effectiveness was more than questionable, whether in the east or on the Italian front. And now we must acknowledge the obvious, the Habsburg potential was not completely denied to Germany, on the contrary, most of it was granted directly to Germany, in the form of the German parts of the Habsburg rule, its suzerainty over Czechoslovakia and even better, an alliance with Romania, not to mention not having to deal with the BEF in France for a good part of the war, so, with Germany having somehow survived the first few years of the war with gains similar to historically, we are now dealing with a Germany much more capable during the Kaiserschlacht than historically, so, with a French army in worse shape, a less powerful and mobilized BEF due to the late entry into the war, it is possible that Paris will be within Heer's reach after all, if this will result in victory It's debatable, but that's my reading.

[MANTARKAFA]

Why would germany be under more pressure in the first scenario they have all of austria and czechoslovakia about 20 million more people to fight with and both of those countries were fairly industrial in that time it doesnt make any sense. Germany got a subject and more people that speak their language while russia got more disgruntled polish nationalists that possibly will revolt and sabotage the russians, in real life czechoslovakia with half the population of poland switched sides and joined russians to fight against austrians and the germans so why wouldnt already rebellious poles do the same but for russia?

[losisansgaming]

18:23 ok italy getting Tunis is unreasonable. One of Britain's main goals in this period was not letting italy get Tunis as then italy controls both of the straights connecting the west and east Mediterranean. Corsica nice and savoy are more likely. Even the horn of Africa territories are more likely

[aimarxv]

I love how Sapin just watches every scenario

[ExPraetorianGuard-dlpz]

Video suggestions:
1) what if Germany concentrated in attacking Russia first instead of France and Belgium in WW1?
2) What if NATO's able archer exercise in 80s triggered WW3?
3) what if Stalin listened to his spies of the Axis army build-up near its border and acted accordingly?
4) What if the French had listened to Belgian intelligence of possible German invasion through ardenne and reinforced it?
5) what if Hitler never redirected the german panzer divisions of the central army group to flank Kiev and just continued to Moscow?
6) what if the Belgians let the Germans pass in WW1?

[iamtheguardsman]

I think the moderate entente victory is the most interesting scenario, would be interested in seeing a follow up as I think this is the only scenario where you have made an Anglo-German alliance possible


Although the heavy entente victory is also interesting because of the powerful Italy, possibly without Mussolini which is also something we don’t see often

[Ea-pbtu]

So the entente loses Britain and the central powers loses Austria Hungary? The central powers nearly won in our timeline, seems like a central powers victory is all but guaranteed here. Britain far surpassed Austria Hungary in strength.

The German fleet was also far stronger than the French and russian ones combined. So no blockade, no starvation, etc.

I disagree with Germany losing the first scenario.

[hellboyhero]

I like the scenario overall, but I think you are underestimating germany a bit. Germany isnt blockaded while France may be and the Ententes War effort isnt payed for by the british in the beginning. As a result Germany would perform way better and I would expect a peace in favour of germany (8:42), Germany to gain a bit more land or maybe some french colonies (16:26) and a longer stalemate with maybe a even peace (20:24) (Germany might even keep one or two puppet states stripped from russia. Alternatively I could also see France completely collapsing if germany can manage to blockade France resulting in a complete German victory.

[paradoxicaloutcome]

So, wait, Germany has more land and population directly integrated into its industry and army, pretty much all the Balkan nations are on the Central Powers' side, the British are not in the war and as a result, the Ottomans are in a much better position... and somehow, the Germans are in the same situation in the same timeframe that they were in OTL's WW1?

With the wider front against Romania and more Ottoman troops in the caucasus, the Russians should be folding a lot faster, while the French are left without British reinforcements for the first half of the war. How does this result in the war going the exact same for Germany unless they end it early? Yes, the Austro-Hungarians are gone, but apart from Hungary, every nation that used to be a part of Austria-Hungary is on the German side, plus Romania.

[winterwarrior]

The scenario with Britain and Germany aligning seems the most interesting

[RIB]

“I will release the follow up on Tuesday”
Meanwhile: on Friday
Also meanwhile: the content absolutely slaps

[Backfyre]

Please continue the first scenario with the German-British Alliance. I mean the German and British Empires working together is a very rare possible history theme and I‘d love to see a continuation of it.

[ussunitedstates]

22:02 the last one look more interesting as it look like prequel for red alert game with soviet starting second world war

[Cymatilus]

First scenario would be the most interesting for a follow up, a German-British alliance is something that I don‘t see explored too often so it has a lot of potential

[altermist]

the main thing i dont understand is at 15:49 where romania gets more of hungary instead of getting moldova from russia? why would they want to add even more hungarians instead of romanians/moldovans?

[seamusfinnegan]

Honestly feel you might be a little harsh on Germanys but solid video and timeline/analysis overall